• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Saturday, April 17, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home National

Psychological Wage: Understanding Trump’s Support in Rural America

Bryan Bowman by Bryan Bowman
09/18/18
in National
Donald Trump at a Florida rally

President Donald Trump addresses a rally at the Orlando Melbourne International Airport, Florida. Photo: AFP

17
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

As a candidate, Donald Trump pitched himself as a champion of the common man. He promised to bring back working-class jobs and return prosperity to “rust belt” communities that were decimated by globalization.

Nearly two years after his electoral victory, those promises have not materialized. So why is then that Trump’s white working-class base continues to support him so adamantly?

The President claims that America’s economy is the “strongest it’s ever been in the history of our country.”

By some metrics, that may be true. Stocks have surged to record highs this year while the unemployment rate is very low. Gross Domestic Product continues to grow steadily, surpassing the elusive four percent mark in the second quarter of 2018.

“You just have to take a look at the numbers … our country is doing phenomenally well,” Trump said in Twitter video in late August. “We’re having a lot of fun.”

But not everyone is doing phenomenally well. A different set of numbers omitted from White House press releases and Fox Business graphics paint a wholly different picture – one in which the large segments of society continue to struggle.


  • 12 percent of Americans, or about 43 million people, live below the poverty line despite being employed.
  • A third of the U.S. population has no savings and another third has less than $1,000 on hand to spare in case of an emergency.
  • America’s youth are straddled with $1.52 trillion in student loan debt collectively.
  • Wages remain stagnant, even as markets continue to grow.
  • Nearly 40 percent of adults say they struggled to meet a basic need such as food, housing, health care or utilities in 2017.

Two Americas

“Over the years, we’ve built two Americas,” Peter Georgescu, Chairman Emeritus of Young & Rubicam Inc., told The Globe Post. “The other America is hiding in plain sight.”

Georgescu himself is a wealthy businessman and a believer in capitalism. He immigrated to the United States from Romania at the age of 15 and went on to become a successful marketing executive.

“I got to live the American Dream. People gave me a chance,” he said.

Somewhere along the way, Georgescu realized that for so many others, that once great notion no longer seemed to be a reality. He’s since dedicated much of his life to advocating for a more just system of capitalism.

“Over the years, we’ve built two Americas. The other America is hiding in plain sight.”

While the America that most people live in continues to face a wide array of economic challenges, the other is indeed “having a lot of fun” under the Trump administration.

“For the top 20 percent of us, life is as good as it gets,” Georgescu said. “Let me tell you, life is great.”

Despite Trump’s populist economic rhetoric, Gerald Friedman, an economist at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, told The Globe Post that the administration’s agenda is really designed to promote the interests of the most wealthy.

Trump’s tax cuts, passed in December, overwhelmingly benefit those in the highest income brackets. While some middle-class families will see small cuts, others will actually have their taxes raised under the bill.   

Large corporations also saw major tax cuts under the new legislation. Many of these companies have used the savings to buy back shares in their own company, driving up the value of their stocks.

“The buybacks make the CEO’s and the shareholders happy … without actually doing anything for the actual functioning of the company,” Friedman, who served as an advisor for Bernie Sanders during his 2016 presidential campaign, said.

Because stock ownership is very highly concentrated among America’s wealthiest people, Georgescu said the boom that resulted from the tax cuts makes little difference for ordinary Americans.

“The way you really pay back your Republican donors is to have a strong stock market,” he said.

Even Trump’s promises to bring back manufacturing jobs through tariffs and new trade deals have proved largely fruitless.

“At this point, not many people work in the industries that he’s trying to protect and he’s going to hurt a lot of people in other industries,” Friedman said. “People in auto plants will lose from higher steel prices because it’s very easy to shift production to Canada or Mexico where there aren’t these tariffs.”

The Culture War

And yet, support for Trump amongst the working class voters who elected him remains steady. An extensive report from Pew Research published in August found the vast majority of Trump voters still feel “warmly” towards him nearly two years after the election.

White working-class voters, particularly in rural communities, played a crucial role in electing Trump. As the historic losers of globalization and automation in the neoliberal era, their economic grievances were very real going into the 2016 election. Yet, by almost any indicator, they’ve reaped very little to no rewards from the Trump economic agenda.

So why is it then that so many in this demographic voted for and continue to support their “class enemy,” in the words of Noam Chomsky?

One answer proposed by Friedman is that the Democratic party has left the rural working class – once a key part of its base in the New Deal era – behind, focusing instead on a more affluent, suburban demographic.

Arlie Hochschild, an influential sociologist at the University of California Berkeley, agrees. She spent five years immersed in a rural Louisiana community that heavily favored Trump doing research for her book, “Strangers in Their Own Land.”

“The general feeling is that they don’t see anything else for them on the political horizon … the Democrats seem to offer nothing for them,” Hochschild told The Globe Post.

But Hochschild proposes another answer as well. By fear mongering on social issues like illegal immigration, the national anthem and religion, Trump has been able to divert attention away from class and towards culture.

“For a lot of the people I talked to, it was very important to elevate their cultural worldview,” she said. “Although the people I met are not white nationalists … they feel that there’s some recognition that whites are declining. They do feel that, and someone is speaking to that.”

Right-wing media also plays a critical role in the diversion, Hochschild said.

“There are certain ideas that are just being hammered in,” she said, citing segments from Fox hosts Tucker Carlson and Laura Ingraham on supposed issues like “demographic changes” and the “crisis for men.”

“For a lot of the people I talked to, it was very important to elevate their cultural worldview.”

As historian Joshua Zeits writes, this is not the first time in U.S. history the working-class has been successfully divided on social issues.

Following the Civil War, poor white farmers and newly emancipated black Americans formed biracial coalition governments around shared economic interests that won elections all across the South.

Their success, however, was short-lived. Wealthy plantation owners drove a wedge between the coalition by stoking fears of “Negro rule” and drumming up marginal social issues like interracial marriage.

“The white group of laborers, while they received a low wage, were compensated in part by a sort of public and psychological wage,” W.E.B Du Bois concluded in his seminal work on Reconstruction.  

By scapegoating immigrants, African Americans, Muslims and other minority groups, Hochschild said the modern Republican party has been able to achieve the same ends.

“It’s a replay of history,” she said, referencing “The Mind of the South,” a classic book by journalist W.J. Cash. “It’s really the mind of poor whites who are being hoodwinked by rich whites in the South. That’s really what that’s about and yea, we’re seeing it again. I think this is a cultural payback. You may be losing economically but you’re still white.”

Trump Says Market Would ‘Crash’ in Case of his Impeachment

Share17Tweet
Bryan Bowman

Bryan Bowman

Email Bryan at bryan.bowman@theglobepost.com or follow him on Twitter @TGPBryanBowman

Related Posts

President Joe Biden
National

Biden Warns Taliban, Presses Pakistan as He Announces Afghan Exit

by Staff Writer
April 14, 2021
WHO director-general Adhanom Ghebreyesus shakes hands with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Beijing, January 28 2020.
Featured

WHO and China: A Healthy Relationship?

by Staff Writer
March 29, 2021
Men and women from various professions walk the streets of Chinatown in Flushing, Queens, nightly.
Featured

Spa Worker, Waiter, Mechanic: New Yorkers Patrol After Anti-Asian Attacks

by Staff Writer
March 26, 2021
Polish President Andrzej Duda speaks at an event.
Democracy at Risk

Polish Writer Charged for Calling President Duda ‘Moron’

by Staff Writer
March 23, 2021
This combination of pictures created on March 17, 2021, shows US President Joe Biden (L) and Russian President Vladimir Putin.
National

Russia Recalls US Envoy After Biden Threatens ‘Killer’ Putin

by Staff Writer
March 18, 2021
Republican Senator from Missouri Josh Hawley
Opinion

Trump’s Acquittal and Republican Senators: Not Setting the Bar Low Enough

by Stephen J. Lyons
February 22, 2021
Next Post
Syrians at a site of car bomb in Idlib

Syria's Neighbors Fear Humanitarian Catastrophe as Assad Moves to Regain Idlib

UK Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn

Englishmen, Zionists, and the Elusive Quality of Irony

Recommended

Myanmar, Buddhists

Myanmar’s Junta Releases 23,000 Prisoners in New Year’s Amnesty

April 17, 2021
Blogger Roy Ngerng

Singapore Activist Crowdfunds $108,000 to Pay PM Libel Damages

April 16, 2021
cyber security

Figuring Out SolarWinds Hack as US Sanctions Russia

April 15, 2021
President Joe Biden

Biden Warns Taliban, Presses Pakistan as He Announces Afghan Exit

April 14, 2021
Egyptian journalist Solafa Magdy (R) and her photojournalist husband Hossam El-Sayed

Egypt Frees Journalist Couple After Jail Time

April 14, 2021
Iranian flag

After Natanz Blast, Iran Vows to Ramp Up Uranium Enrichment

April 13, 2021

Opinion

A candlelight vigil in Garden Grove, California, after the shooting that left eight people dead in Atlanta, including six Asian women

American Nightmare: The Asian-American Experience

April 17, 2021
Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson delivers a speech, 2016

The Hippocratic Oath Stops at the Arkansas Border

April 8, 2021
Erdogan Threatens to Open Europe Gates for Refugees

Turkey’s Latest Crackdown Spells Dangerous New Normal for Human Rights Defenders

March 29, 2021
President Biden speaks about the Colorado shootings at the White House.

US Gun Violence: Biden, You Need to Do Something. Now

March 26, 2021
COVID Stimulus Checks: Does Victory Include Abandoning the Most Vulnerable?

COVID Stimulus Checks: Does Victory Include Abandoning the Most Vulnerable?

March 25, 2021
A couple wearing facemasks to prevent the spread of coronavirus watch the sunset from Elysian Park in Los Angeles, California, last month.

Why We Should Expect a Roaring ’20s 2.0 for Our New Normal

March 16, 2021
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post