• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Wednesday, February 1, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Midterms post Mortem: why American Democracy is Broken

Daniel P. Franklin by Daniel P. Franklin
11/12/18
in Opinion
Voter casting a ballot during the 2018 US midterm elections.

Photo: Bill Wechter, AFP

10
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

While Democrats can breathe a sigh of relief on the results of the latest midterm elections, their wins beg the question of whether this election served any useful purpose. I would assume that the ultimate goal of any government is to make good public policy. But by winning a majority in the House, the Democrats did not gain sufficient clout to advance policies that are at the core of the Democratic agenda. Nobody really thinks that is going to happen. What the Democrats have gained, however, is the power to hamstring the opposition. What practical purpose does that serve?

American democracy is in trouble. It is an 18th-century model in a 21st-century world. As I often say to my students, “the Framers set out to design a government that didn’t work very well, and they were enormously successful.” Now that is true, more than ever.

American Constitution

The American government was designed to impose a number of barriers to policymaking. The idea was that an inefficient government would be restrained from violating the rights of its citizens. If we divine the original intent of the Framers, we find that the “citizens” they were trying to protect were themselves: white male property owners. And in that endeavor, they were pretty successful. Of course, that construct leaves out a lot of shareholders who are now considered citizens. Thus, in the strictest sense, the Constitution was never really a democratic design to begin with.

Happy Constitution Day! https://t.co/9KiLowP3Hh

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 17, 2018

Now that the definition of citizenship has been expanded to include all naturalized and native adults, the structure of the Constitution is not well adapted to popular consent. Instead, the excessive protections of (numerical) minority rights have made it impossible to govern.

Predictably, this problem became manifest fairly recently with the passage and implementation of the Voting Rights Act in 1965. Increasingly, it becomes clear that under the current Constitution, the country becomes ungovernable if everyone is actually allowed to participate.

Let’s consider the ways in which our Constitution fails.

Annual Budget

First, the Federal Government is unable to carry out its most basic functions. The primary example of this is its inability to produce an annual budget. Congress has not passed a complete budget (all 12 standalone appropriations bills) since 1997, and between 2011 and 2016, it passed none of its regular appropriations bills at all.

As a result, many lingering policy concerns remain. Furthermore, without the capacity to make decisions, once something happens, it is almost impossible to reverse. That includes budget deficits, a creaky inefficient health care system, and a war that is now 17 years old.

One Person One Vote?

A second way in which the Constitution fails is that the Federal Government can no longer be construed in any way to be a democracy. None of the major institutions at the Federal level represent the principle of one person one vote.

The Senate is a manifestly undemocratic institution, made more so by the recent dismissal of the supermajority requirement (for, among other things, the confirmation of judges). Apropos of which the Courts are undemocratic institutions which, because of the failure of the Government’s policy-making function, are increasingly tasked with making policy decisions for the country.

The House of Representatives is undemocratic because the districting principle skews the representation of the institution. There is a historical “seat bonus” for the majority party such that in 2016 the Republicans won the popular vote (for the House) by only about 1.5 percent but held a 10 percent advantage in seats held after the election.  This year was an anomaly in that the seat bonus is very small, 51.5 percent of the vote for 53 percent of the seats, but we would expect in the long run for the system to revert to the mean.

Finally, the presidency is an undemocratic institution because of the Electoral College.  Unfaithful electors aside, in my own research (with Tyler Harville), I can demonstrate that the “Senate Skew” (two votes added to each state in relation to their Senate representation) in the Electoral College would have changed the outcome in two presidential elections since the turn of the 20th-century, including 2000 which without the Senate Skew, Al Gore would have won (even without Florida). The other is 1916, with Charles Evans Hughes winning the presidency (hey conservatives, he was opposed to the income tax!).

For a number of years, Conservatives have been agitating for a new Constitutional Convention. Their real purpose is to get a Balanced Budget Amendment to the Constitution and limits on the power of the Federal Government.

Maybe it’s time for liberals to agree, not with the Balanced Budget Amendment, mind you, but with the principle of a constitutional convention perhaps for the purpose of turning the United States into a democracy.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
Share10Tweet
Daniel P. Franklin

Daniel P. Franklin

Associate Professor Emeritus, Georgia State University

Related Posts

Top view of the US House of Representatives
National

Chaos as US House Adjourns Without Choosing Speaker

by Staff Writer
January 4, 2023
President Donald Trump and US Attorney General William Barr step off Air Force One upon arrival at Andrews Air Force Base in Maryland last September 1, 2020.
National

US Attorney General Says No Evidence of Decisive Election Fraud

by Staff Writer
December 2, 2020
An election worker handles vote-by-mail ballots for the presidential primary in Renton, Washington on March 10, 2020. Photo: Jason Redmond/AFP.
Democracy at Risk

Voter Suppression: The Unsung Virus of 2020

by Jonah Fox
August 10, 2020
Smoke rises from the site of an attack on Tuesday after a massive explosion the night before near the Green Village in Kabul, Afghanistan
Featured

Afghan War Crimes Probe Must Go Ahead, ICC Judges Say

by Staff Writer
March 5, 2020
NATO to Review Iraq Mission After Parliament Votes to Expel US Forces
Featured

NATO to Review Iraq Mission After Parliament Votes to Expel US Forces

by Staff Writer
January 6, 2020
US President Donald Trump
Featured

How the World is Reacting to US Killing of Top Iran General

by Staff Writer
January 3, 2020
Next Post
A men enters the WTO building

Is World Trade Organization Still Relevant?

Rohingya refugees reaching for food aid at Kutupalong refugee camp in Bangladesh

Rohingya Flee Bangladesh Camps Fearing Forcible Return to Myanmar

Recommended

A supporter of nurses' strike and NHS holds a placard

UK Faces Fresh Mass Strikes as Wage Talks Derail

February 1, 2023
Israeli security forces in Jerusalem

Palestinian Gunman Kills 7 in East Jerusalem Synagogue Attack

January 30, 2023
The Doomsday Clock reads 100 seconds to midnight, a decision made by The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, during an announcement at the National Press Club in Washington, DC on January 23, 2020

‘Doomsday Clock’ Moves Closest Ever to Midnight

January 25, 2023
Police work near the scene of a mass shooting in Monterey Park, California

California Lunar New Year Mass Shooter Dead, Motive Unclear: Police

January 23, 2023
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern

Race on To Replace Ardern as New Zealand Prime Minister

January 20, 2023
Pfizer logo and vaccines

Pfizer to Sell More Drugs at Cost to Poor Nations

January 18, 2023

Opinion

George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023
Commuters waiting for buses in Metro Manila. Philippines

Eight Billion and Counting…

November 29, 2022
Mahsa Amini protests

Imagining a Free Iran

October 24, 2022
Vladimir Putin

How 18th Century International Law Clarifies the Situation in Ukraine

September 29, 2022
Vladimir Putin

Falling for Putin

September 15, 2022
US President Donald Trump

Donald Trump Thanks You for Your Sacrifice

August 17, 2022
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post