• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Thursday, January 26, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

New Efforts to Reform World Trade Organization are Critical

Valerie Hughes by Valerie Hughes
11/29/18
in Opinion
Building of the World Trade Organization (WTO)

Photo: Abrice Coffrini, AFP

10
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Multilateralism has lost its sheen in some circles. So too some of the institutions that foster and depend on it. The global trading system, with the World Trade Organization (WTO) at its core, is not immune to current anti-globalization sentiments. Indeed, the Director-General of the WTO says it is facing a crisis.

No surprise, therefore, that we are witnessing several high-level initiatives aimed at reforming the WTO. Of course, there have been previous calls to modernize the institution but the various recommendations generally went unheeded. But this time, the reform efforts are different, coming as they do from a sense of urgency felt intensely by WTO members themselves.

Why the sense of urgency? Primarily it is due to the impending collapse of the WTO dispute settlement system. For the first time since the WTO was established in 1995, the WTO Appellate Body is in danger of grinding to a halt due to the failure of WTO members to appoint appellate body members (“judges”) to hear appeals.

If that happens, WTO members will no longer be able to challenge non-compliance with WTO rules, a powerful tool that both developed and developing countries have used close to 600 times so far.

So, what’s stopping the members from appointing new judges?

Basically, it’s the WTO system of doing things by consensus. For almost two years now, the United States has vetoed the launch of a process to fill seats of retired judges on the 7-member Appellate Body, which is now down to three members (Ujal Singh Bhatia from India, Thomas Graham from the United States, and Hong Zhao from China).

WTO's appellate body — which issues finale rulings in trade disputes and is branded as @wto "crown jewel" — is now down to three judges, the absolute minimum, after US today blocked the reappointment of Mauritian judge S. Servansing @POLITICOEurope https://t.co/U439f88QGs

— vonderburchard (@vonderburchard) August 27, 2018

The rules require that three members must hear each appeal, so if one of them is unable to serve on a particular case due to a conflict of interest, that appeal cannot be heard and the case will remain undecided. Moreover, when judges Bhatia and Graham finish their terms one year from now, leaving only Zhao from China on the bench, it will not be possible for any new appeal to proceed.

Frustration with Appellate Body

The United States’ veto of the appointment process stems from its profound dissatisfaction with the Appellate Body on a number of fronts.

A men enters the WTO building
WTO was established in 1995. Photo: APF

The U.S. considers that the Appellate Body has often engaged in expansive interpretations that effectively create new law (including in the area of state-sponsored subsidies), has regularly gone beyond its mandate by issuing findings that are not necessary to resolve a dispute, has flouted the rules by failing to meet the 90-day deadline for conducting appeals, and has failed to seek WTO members’ approval to allow appellate judges whose terms have expired to complete appeals they started prior to their terms ending.

The United States wants these and other concerns addressed before it gives its approval to start a selection process to fill empty seats on the Appellate Body. Other WTO members say they are ready to work on solutions, but maintain that Appellate Body appointments are not linked to these concerns and must proceed.

Despite both public and backroom efforts to break the deadlock, no progress has been made.

US and China Trade War

Another serious issue plaguing the WTO is its inability to curb rising trade tensions between the United States and China. The U.S. has complained that China’s non-market-oriented practices create unfair competitive conditions. It has also accused China of intellectual property theft and forcing foreign companies to transfer technology and trade secrets through joint ventures, licensing requirements, and other practices.

Chart showing Trump's China tariffs

Maintaining that WTO rules are insufficient to respond to these concerns, the U.S. has imposed tariffs on billions of dollars of Chinese products, which has prompted China to retaliate in kind.

The United States has also imposed steep tariffs on steel and aluminum products from numerous countries alleging security concerns, with the result that several countries have hit back with their own tariffs on U.S. goods. These actions have led to numerous legal challenges at the WTO, but these procedures may never get resolved if the WTO dispute settlement mechanism ceases to function.

Saving the WTO

Jim Carr, Canada's Minister for International Trade Diversification, speaks at the World Trade Organization reform talks in Ottawa in October.
Canada’s Minister for International Trade Diversification Jim Carr. Photo: Lars Hagberg, AFP

Against this backdrop, several WTO members are working to “save” the WTO.

One such initiative is being led by Canadian International Trade Diversification Minister Jim Carr. Last month, he invited twelve trade ministers from across the globe (including Australia, Brazil, Kenya, and Korea but not including the U.S. or China) to a meeting in Ottawa to discuss the Appellate Body impasse as well as to consider other ideas for modernizing the WTO.

In a joint communique, the ministers identified some areas requiring urgent consideration. Their first priority is an effective dispute settlement system, which they described as a central pillar of the WTO. They acknowledged the concerns raised about the functioning of the Appellate Body and indicated a willingness to seek solutions, but they emphasized the urgent need to unblock the appointment process. For them, the continued vacancies in the Appellate Body present a risk to the WTO system as a whole. They undertook to report progress in January.

These ministers have set themselves a daunting task. But they must succeed. And they must move quickly.

The WTO dispute settlement mechanism is the foundation of the rules-based trading system and is the only available means of ensuring compliance with multilateral trade rules.

To be sure, the system has its flaws and improvements need to be made. The U.S. has some valid concerns. But the system has served WTO members – including its top users the U.S., the E.U., and Canada – pretty well for over 20 years, so it is important to preserve its essential features. Everyone will have to put a little water in their wine but it will be worth it to save the WTO.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
Share10Tweet
Valerie Hughes

Valerie Hughes

Senior Counsel with the Ottawa office of Bennett Jones LLP and adjunct assistant professor of international trade law at Queen's University in Kingston, Canada. Hughes was Director of the Legal Affairs Division of the World Trade Organization from 2010 to 2016 and Director of the WTO Appellate Body Secretariat from 2001 to 2005

Related Posts

A woman undergoing COVID test in China
Featured

Soaring Covid Cases Shine Light on China’s Healthcare Gap

by Staff Writer
January 11, 2023
Donald Trump
National

US Supreme Court Freezes Release of Trump Tax Returns

by Staff Writer
November 1, 2022
Donald Trump
National

US Capitol Riot Probe Votes to Subpoena Trump to Testify

by Staff Writer
October 13, 2022
Members of the Muslim Uyghurs minority demonstrate
World

EU to Ban Products Made Using Forced Labor, Risking China Anger

by Staff Writer
September 14, 2022
Steve Bannon
National

Former Trump Advisor Bannon Charged With Fraud in New York

by Staff Writer
September 8, 2022
China Uyghurs
World

US Says UN Report Shows Xinjiang ‘Genocide’ as China Irate

by Staff Writer
September 1, 2022
Next Post
A Palestinian family walks on August 27, 2014, past the collapsed remains of a building in Shejaiya that was destroyed in fighting between Hamas and Israel

Recalibrating and Relieving Pressure: Israel and Hamas Need Violent Episodes

German police raid Deutsche Bank

German Police Raid Deutsche Bank in 'Panama Papers' Probe

Recommended

The Doomsday Clock reads 100 seconds to midnight, a decision made by The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, during an announcement at the National Press Club in Washington, DC on January 23, 2020

‘Doomsday Clock’ Moves Closest Ever to Midnight

January 25, 2023
Police work near the scene of a mass shooting in Monterey Park, California

California Lunar New Year Mass Shooter Dead, Motive Unclear: Police

January 23, 2023
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern

Race on To Replace Ardern as New Zealand Prime Minister

January 20, 2023
Pfizer logo and vaccines

Pfizer to Sell More Drugs at Cost to Poor Nations

January 18, 2023
Rescuers inspect the wreckage at the site of a Yeti Airlines plane crash in Pokhara, Nepal

At Least 67 Killed in Nepal Plane Crash

January 16, 2023
George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023

Opinion

George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023
Commuters waiting for buses in Metro Manila. Philippines

Eight Billion and Counting…

November 29, 2022
Mahsa Amini protests

Imagining a Free Iran

October 24, 2022
Vladimir Putin

How 18th Century International Law Clarifies the Situation in Ukraine

September 29, 2022
Vladimir Putin

Falling for Putin

September 15, 2022
US President Donald Trump

Donald Trump Thanks You for Your Sacrifice

August 17, 2022
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post