• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Wednesday, March 29, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Migrant Containment at all Costs: What is Left of European Humanity?

Helen O'Nions by Helen O'Nions
02/14/19
in Opinion
Rescued Cameroonian migrant Josepha, 40-years-old, rests on board the Spanish NGO Proactiva Open Arms boat as it sails back to Spain in the Mediterranean Sea on July 17, 2018

Photo: Pau Barrena, AFP

38
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Back in 2012, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Italy was in breach of various fundamental human rights when Italian coastguards had intercepted three vessels packed with Eritrean and Somali migrants and forced to return them to Libya. The action of interception had established a jurisdictional link making the Italian authorities responsible for the treatment of those on board (both at sea and back in Libya).

The decision sent a clear message that fundamental rights under the European Convention, particularly the prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment, should be respected regardless of the nationality of the rights holder and the location of the interception.

It also had the unintended consequence of contributing to a “look the other way” migration policy that has come to characterize the European response to migration, including asylum.

At the height of Europe’s self-proclaimed “migration crisis” in 2015-16 when an estimated 1.4 million people sought asylum in the E.U., there were over 4,969 recorded deaths in the Mediterranean. The International Organization for Migration proclaimed the journey from North Africa to Italy as the world’s most lethal route. While European states argued over how to prevent irregular migration, they continued to ignore the unfolding humanitarian tragedy at their border, as well as their role in its making.

Turning Point

The case of the drowned toddler Aylan Kurdi appeared to mark a turning point in the public’s understanding of the plight of asylum seekers. European governments and mainstream media were forced to take a more sympathetic angle, moving away (albeit briefly) from the economic migrant and bogus asylum narratives so ubiquitous in the European media.

The lifeless body of three-year-old Aylan Kurdi, found on a Turkish beach, became the symbol of the refugee crisis
The lifeless body of three-year-old Aylan Kurdi became the symbol of the refugee crisis. Photo: AFP

The U.K., under former Prime Minister David Cameron, promised to extend the Syrian Vulnerable Persons Relocation scheme to take in 20,000 Syrian refugees “to fulfill its moral responsibility.” The precise figure ascribed to this moral obligation needs perhaps to be viewed in the light of almost 7 million externally displaced Syrians, many of whom are effectively trapped in camps in the immediate region. They have no legal route to rebuild their lives and are expected to remain, in existential limbo, until Bashar al-Assad’s regime finally crumbles and it becomes safe to return.

The containment of irregular migrants, in regions of origin and removed from the relative safety of Europe, is now the dominant policy of the European Union. The E.U.-Turkey deal which saw the relocation of migrants from Greece to Turkey with the remote possibility of European resettlement for those that qualified under the limited terms of the agreement, exemplifies this “out of sight, out of mind” approach. While it fails to guarantee the right to enjoy refugee status (Turkey does not allow a claim for permanent refugee status), it also fails to acknowledge the desperation of those contained and the impact on host communities.

International Right to Asylum

Conditions in Libya, particularly for sub-Saharan migrants, remain dire. Arbitrary detention, torture, and widespread abuse have been well-documented by human rights organizations and are revealed in the harrowing testimony of survivors. Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have documented hundreds of cases of abuse in official detention centers.

"They make us sit and look straight at the sun." ~ "Elijah" from Sierra Leone @hrw found violent abuse by guards in four official detention centers in western #Libya. https://t.co/fRGpBj0gAK pic.twitter.com/yQLWPJpcKg

— Human Rights Watch (@hrw) January 21, 2019

The UNHCR has long advocated a safe passage route from Libya yet this has repeatedly been blocked by European governments anxious to ensure that there is no deviation from the “prevent and deter” strategy.

Meanwhile, European governments have viewed the Libyan authorities as key partners in the fight against irregular migration. It is perhaps worth stating that irregular migration is a catch-all term that inevitably includes refugees, those fleeing civil war, and unaccompanied child migrants, along with those crudely termed economic migrants. Any initiatives to prevent or deter such migration will, therefore, prevent those fleeing persecution from exercising their international right to seek and enjoy asylum safe from persecution.

Humanitarian Tragedy in Mediterranean

As one migratory route closes, another always opens. The greater the risk of detection, the greater the smugglers’ fee. Increased surveillance off the Libyan coast has resulted in the dispersal of migratory departure points across North Africa, seriously compromising the ability of those engaged in search and rescue to save lives.

A humanitarian tragedy is occurring in the Mediterranean, made considerably worse by the behavior of some European governments that have impounded search and rescue vessels operated by humanitarian missions on the pretext that they encourage smugglers.

In January, the German-registered Sea-Watch 3 rescued 47 people, including 15 unaccompanied minors, from a rubber dinghy off the coast of Libya. Having been refused permission to dock in Italy for eleven days, the crew made an emergency application to the European Court.

After the Court required that the Italian authorities “take all necessary measures, as soon as possible, to provide all the applicants with adequate medical care, food, water, and basic supplies as necessary,” a deal to relocate the arrivals was struck with seven European governments.

Vacuum of Responsibility

There is now a vacuum of responsibility at the heart of the European Union. The absence of decisive leadership has led the UN’s High Commissioner for Refugees to condemn a European competition to deny responsibility. The heavily resourced E.U. Frontex agency has recently revised (and narrowed) its Triton mission after extensive criticism from the Italian authorities. Themis will focus on criminal activity, closer to the Italian coast and, crucially, will rescue only “if asked.”

As a result, the chances of dying in the Mediterranean are now far greater than ever, with one person drowning for every 57 that arrive safely.

Brendan Woodhouse, a member of the Sea-Watch crew, suggests the number is actually far greater as many drown without ever being recorded or documented. He told me that the only government vessels now patrolling the region are those of the Libyan coastguard, funded by European governments. He characterizes their response to search and rescue as comprising “hostility, haste and bad practice.” Even more worrying is the allegation from those recently rescued that members of the Libyan coastguard were involved in their detention and torture back in Libya.

Today a baby learns to walk on the Seawatch 3. End her needless imprisonment in the sea. Open the ports and let her walk on land.

Photo taken and shared with her mother’s permission pic.twitter.com/hfq8I2Ilhh

— Brendan Woodhouse (@BrendanWoodhous) January 8, 2019

The principles of common humanity and international refugee law are being routinely undermined. In one recent incident north of Libyan port city Al Khoms a cargo ship picked up survivors, including women and children who had been left stranded for two days. They were immediately returned to Libya in clear breach of the principles established in the 2012 Hirsi Jamaa case and the international obligation of non-refoulment.

Woodhouse is uncompromising in his criticism: “Can you imagine a world where 47 white people were allowed to drown by European governments? Can you imagine if they were rescued by someone, that their rescuers would be accused of being criminals? If it was white people, can you imagine? … neither can I.”

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
Share38Tweet
Helen O'Nions

Helen O'Nions

Associate Professor of Law at the Nottingham Trent University

Related Posts

Mario Draghi
Business

EU Leaders Clash Over How to Tackle Energy Prices

by Staff Writer
October 20, 2022
Olaf Scholz
Business

Germany Defends Massive Energy Plan Against EU Critics

by Staff Writer
October 4, 2022
EU flags
World

Europe Tries to Save Energy Ahead of Winter in Face of Ukraine War

by Staff Writer
August 26, 2022
EU flags
World

EU Slaps Sanctions on Syrians Accused of Recruiting Mercenaries for Russia

by Staff Writer
July 21, 2022
gold bars
Business

European Union to Target Russian Gold With New Sanctions

by Staff Writer
July 15, 2022
Eurozone
Business

Eurozone Stocks Sink as Inflation Accelerates to Record High

by Staff Writer
May 31, 2022
Next Post
school violence parkland

One Year After Parkland, Trump Vows He Will 'Not Rest' Until Schools Safe

US Senate to Vote on Yemen War as Near-Apocalyptic Disaster There Looms

Humanitarian Catastrophe in Yemen Getting Even Worse [UN Report]

Recommended

Damage from a series of powerful storms and at least one tornado is seen on March 25, 2023, in Rolling Fork, Mississippi

After Tornado Kills 25, Mississippi Faces More Extreme Weather

March 26, 2023
Transgender Army veteran Tanya Walker speaks to protesters in Times Square near a military recruitment centre

Tennessee Is A Drag on the First Amendment

March 26, 2023
participants of an artificial intelligence conference

How AI Could Upend the World Even More Than Electricity or the Internet

March 19, 2023
Chinese President Xi Jinping

China’s Path to Economic Dominance

March 15, 2023
Heavily armed police inspect the area near a Jehovah's Witness church where several people have been killed in a shooting in Hamburg, northern Germany

Eight Dead in Shooting at Jehovah’s Witness Hall in Germany

March 10, 2023
Myanmar Rohingya refugees look on in a refugee camp in Teknaf, in Bangladesh's Cox's Bazar, on November 26, 2016

US Announces $26M in New Aid for Rohingya

March 8, 2023

Opinion

Transgender Army veteran Tanya Walker speaks to protesters in Times Square near a military recruitment centre

Tennessee Is A Drag on the First Amendment

March 26, 2023
Chinese President Xi Jinping

China’s Path to Economic Dominance

March 15, 2023
An earthquake survivor reacts as rescuers look for victims and other survivors in Hatay, a Turkish province where hundreds of buildings were destroyed by the earthquake

Heed the Call of Our Broken World

March 1, 2023
Top view of the US House of Representatives

‘Cringy Awards:’ Who Is the Most Embarrassing US House Representative?

February 13, 2023
Protesters rally against the fatal police assault of Tyre Nichols, outside of the Coleman A. Young Municipal Center in Detroit, Michigan, on January 27, 2023

How Do Violent ‘Monsters’ Take Root?

February 3, 2023
George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post