• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Tuesday, June 24, 2025
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Modi’s High Stakes Gamble: How Will India’s Citizenship Act Play Out?

Peter Mayer and Mandar Oak by Peter Mayer and Mandar Oak
12/30/19
in Opinion
The new citizenship law has sparked two weeks of protests across India

The new citizenship law has sparked weeks of protests across India. Photo: Manjunath Kiran, AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Indian parliament, dominated by the Hindu right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), recently passed the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA). This contentious bill selectively relaxes restrictions for unauthorized (and hence, illegal) migrants and refugees to obtain Indian citizenship. Unauthorized immigrants who entered the country from neighboring Islamic Afghanistan, Bangladesh, and Pakistan before 2015 can now become Indian citizens – but not if they are Muslim.

The act is discriminatory in its choice of minorities and countries, especially in leaving out neighboring countries where Muslims are a religious minority facing persecution. Rohingyas in Myanmar are a case in point.

At the same time, the government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi has also announced its intention to formulate a nationwide National Register of Citizens (NRC), a comprehensive list of all Indian citizens. Such a list has recently been created for the north-eastern state of Assam, where unauthorized immigration, as well as an influx of non-Assamese settlers from other parts of India, has been a political flashpoint for decades.

India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Photo: AFP

Viewed in isolation, both the CAA and NRC look like reasonable policies. Even with the preferential treatment of some religions over others, the CAA may be considered an improvement in that it offers help to some unauthorized migrants without changing the status of the left out unauthorized Muslim migrants. And the NRC is just a list of citizens, something which has been on the cards for a while.

However, once the CAA and NRC are put together and understood in the context of the ruling government’s political ideology, things get scary. And then, one can appreciate why there were nationwide protests against the CAA over the last few weeks.

Politics Behind CAA-NRC

The Hindu right has long insisted that Bangladeshi Muslims have been infiltrating the porous India-Bangladesh border and have been settling into India’s north-east. Various left-leaning political parties are alleged to have ignored, if not encouraged, this influx. Reliable statistics of how many Bangladeshis have entered India, whether Hindu or Muslim, are hard to find, leading to many widely differing estimates.

The Hindu right succeeded in forming alliances with local political parties in the north-east who were fighting for the rights of locals over outsiders, including Indians from other states, especially from West Bengal. Equating the (primarily Hindu) locals with Indian citizens and outsiders with Bangladeshi Muslims suited both parties’ agenda and hence sustained their coalition. Then, per an accord between the government and local rights activists, an NRC was created for the state of Assam with the hope of separating natives from the outsiders.

However, when the first draft of the Assam NRC was released, it excluded many who were self-evidently citizens, including relatives of a former Indian president and ex-Indian army personnel. It also became evident that many excluded from the list were Hindus, who apparently could not produce the necessary documentation to prove their citizenship or whose documents had minor clerical errors such as spelling of names. In addition, the number of those excluded (some 1.9 million) fell considerably short of the expected number of outsiders that the NRC exercise was expected to identify and exclude.

BJP Faces Backlash 

The listing of large numbers of Bengali-speaking Hindus as non-citizens led to a backlash from the BJP’s Bengali Hindu constituency. In response, the BJP abruptly changed tack by questioning the NRC’s validity. The party also intensified its push for the CAA, since the amendment would provide a way for Bengali Hindu residents excluded from citizenship to be brought back onto the register while keeping out Muslims.

And then, to compound its embarrassment, the government announced that the registry exercise would be extended to the entire country and all unauthorized – essentially Muslim – outsiders will be “thrown out.” Several detention centers to hold those deemed illegal under the NRC are already constructed, while many more are on the way.

In light of the nightmarish examples of inaccuracies in the Assam NRC exercise, this announcement has created an atmosphere of anxiety and besiegement among Indian Muslims. Students on university campuses around the country, left-leaning parties, and those who feel the CAA-NRC policy is a threat to Indian secularism have joined in the protest.

Modi’s Good Cop, Bad Cop Approach

In the face of popular rejection, Prime Minister Modi and his government have seemed to adopt a “good cop, bad cop” approach.

One the one hand, Modi has accused opponents of being revolutionary Marxists or Pakistani sympathizers who are spreading “white lies” about government schemes. On the other hand, he has assured citizens that the policies will have no effect on either Indian Hindus or Muslims and even denied that there is any plan to roll out a nationwide NRC.

Given the widespread protests against the CAA-NRC, one might ask why the Modi government persists with it. One suggested answer is that the approach is a tactic which the BJP hopes will consolidate its Hindu Bengali vote in the West Bengal elections scheduled for December 2020. Will it work? Possibly.

Protesters shout slogans during a demonstration against India's new citizenship law in Allahabad on December 19, 2019
Protesters shout slogans during a demonstration against India’s new citizenship law. Photo: Sanjay Kanojia, AFP

This policy shows similarities with the 2016 demonetization of high-value rupee notes. The demonetization was a poorly planned, hastily executed, ultimately futile exercise. Still, despite causing widespread hardship, especially for the poor, the Indian electorate does not seem to have politically punished the BJP.

However, the policy may have adverse repercussions in other states, especially since many BJP allies have refused to participate in the NRC exercise.

This can play out in two ways. Either it will damage the BJP in states where its votes come indirectly through allies, or it could lead to Hindu voters in these states abandoning the regional parties and directly voting for the BJP. In this sense, the BJP seems to be playing a high stakes gamble.

However, as a policy, it is far from clear that even if such an exercise succeeds in identifying infiltrators, it is feasible to deport such people. Additionally, the human and economic costs of the practice are hard to justify in the face of uncertain gains this policy may bring.

At the same time, it has already dented India’s international reputation and created a communal rift at home, which will hurt the country’s economic prospects at this crucial moment.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Peter Mayer and Mandar Oak

Peter Mayer and Mandar Oak

Mayer is Associate Professor of Politics and Visiting Research Fellow at the University of Adelaide. Oak is Associate Professor of Economics at the University of Adelaide

Related Posts

Protesters stand with placards in front of the statue of India's independence leader Mahatma Gandhi in Parliament Square, central London, after a demonstration outside the US Embassy
Featured

Considering the Patience of Gandhi for These Troubled Times

by Stephen J. Lyons
August 5, 2022
India hijab ban
World

Protests Over Classroom Hijab Ban Grow in India

by Staff Writer
February 7, 2022
Around 2,500 people die in lightning strikes around India each year. Photo: Rakesh Bakshi/AFP/File
Environment

Climate Crisis Triggers Spike in Lightning Strike Deaths in India

by Staff Writer
September 3, 2021
Taj Mahal
Lifestyle

Taj Mahal Reopens as India Eases Pandemic Restrictions

by Staff Writer
June 16, 2021
Covid-19 in Brazil
Featured

No Pandemic End in Sight With Raging Outbreaks in India, Brazil

by Staff Writer
May 1, 2021
Rescue workers search for survivors in the debris of a collapsed building in Mahad, India on Tuesday. AFP
World

‘Like a House of Cards:’ Building Collapses in India, Killing 11

by Anya Ruppert
August 26, 2020
Next Post
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio. Photo: AFP

New York Mayor Decries 'Crisis' of Anti-Semitism After Attack

Iraqi protesters set a sentry box ablaze in the area of the US embassy compound in Baghdad. December 31, 2019. Photo: AFP

Iraqi Protesters Attack US Embassy Over Deadly Strikes

Recommended

An Iranian protester

Iran’s Nuclear Program: From Its Origins to Today’s Dispute

June 23, 2025
Protesters and police clash during the “No Kings” protest in Los Angeles, California on June 14, 2025.

US Appeals Court Allows Trump Control of National Guard in LA

June 20, 2025
Donald Trump

Fact vs. Fiction: The Trump Administration’s Dubious War on Reverse Discrimination

June 18, 2025
Iranian missiles and Israeli interceptors light up the sky over Beirut, Lebanon, on June 14, 2025. Iran launched multiple missiles toward Israeli targets, triggering interception attempts above several regional capitals, including Beirut.

Israel-Iran Conflict: Latest Developments

June 18, 2025
Tens of thousands of protestors shut down Fifth Avenue in Manhattan on Saturday, April 5, 2025, protesting the Trump administration's abuse of the separation of federal powers as well as the deep cuts to governmental services overseen by presidential advisor Elon Musk.

Civil Society Is Holding the Line. Will Washington Notice?

June 17, 2025
An Iranian walking in front of a wall painting of the Iranian flag in Tehran

How Much Damage Has Israel Inflicted on Iran’s Nuclear Program?

June 16, 2025

Opinion

Donald Trump

Fact vs. Fiction: The Trump Administration’s Dubious War on Reverse Discrimination

June 18, 2025
Tens of thousands of protestors shut down Fifth Avenue in Manhattan on Saturday, April 5, 2025, protesting the Trump administration's abuse of the separation of federal powers as well as the deep cuts to governmental services overseen by presidential advisor Elon Musk.

Civil Society Is Holding the Line. Will Washington Notice?

June 17, 2025
A Black Lives Matter mural in New York City.

Fuhgeddaboudit! America’s Erasure of History

April 2, 2025
Bust of Deputy Rubens Paiva in the Chamber of Deputies

Democratic Brazilians Are Still Here

March 18, 2025
A woman from Guatemala

Dispatch From Central America

January 28, 2025
US President Donald Trump

Dear Trump Supporters: Is This the America You Wanted?

January 28, 2025
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post