• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Wednesday, April 14, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Modi’s Narrow and Intolerant Idea of India Is Backfiring

Saheli Khastagir by Saheli Khastagir
02/05/20
in Opinion
A protester displays a placard during a demonstration against India's new citizenship law

A protester displays a placard during a demonstration against India's new citizenship law. Photo: Jewel Samad, AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Last week, a gunman in India’s capital New Delhi shot at a group of peaceful protesters demonstrating against the country’s contentious Citizenship Amendment Act. Dozens of police armed to the teeth casually watched while he yelled things like “Yeh lo Azaazi” (here take your freedom) and “Delhi Police Zindabad” (long live Delhi police).

The police watched as the perpetrator brandished his gun at the group, when the protesters and the media recording the event begged for intervention, and when he finally pulled the trigger. They also watched as the student injured in this show of impotent rage climbed over the barricades they had set up to make his way to the hospital.

Only after that man’s bullet hit that student spurting out blood and disbelief, the police escorted the gunman into their jeep and arrested him.

Some might look at this and comment on the inefficiency of the Indian police, but that would be unfair. The police are, eerily so, very efficient at what they are doing. They are acting as the state’s tool to give a very specific message to the nation: we will protect you as long as you submit to our idea of India, an India in which only some will enjoy the patronage of the state.

Harsh Retaliation Against Protestors

Sadly, the university shooting of last week is not an isolated incident. Just over a month ago, the Delhi police entered the same university, pulling protesting students from under library tables, injuring over 100 of them, and traumatizing many more for years to come. What then seemed unbelievable, in the following weeks got repeated in other universities, at different protest sites, and in other states.

Since protests against the Citizenship Amendment Act began in December, at least 25 people have been killed. Videos have surfaced of women protecting unarmed men from the police’s batons and boots, and images were spread on social media showing the police questioning 4th-graders over their alleged participation in a play that portrayed Prime Minister Narendra Modi “in poor light.”

India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Photo: Prakash Singh, AFP

Indians across the country are calling friends and family to make sure they return home safely. They are sending out SOS messages for medical and food aid in the indefinite sit-ins that have sprung up in all of India’s corners. The sit-in participants take turns sharing food, songs, hope, poetry, slogans, and energy in between their homework, jobs, classes, and errands.

These participants, unwittingly, are challenging the very idea of India that the ruling party is trying to project.

With its superb diversity and inclusivity, the spontaneous nation-wide protests are filling the streets with Indians of all classes, castes, and genders. They draw Indians speaking different tongues, with different educational backgrounds, different privileges, and even different political leanings, challenging the government’s narrow idea of India.

These protests are no longer just about one law or one policy. They have evolved into nothing short of a demonstration of the multitude that India is capable of and that the BJP Hindu nationalist government is determined to throttle.

Modi’s India

This has become painfully evident over the last year. In August, a district court in the northern state of Rajasthan acquitted the men who had lynched 55-year-old Pehlu Khan, one of the dozens who have died in the cow vigilante violence that has rocked India since Modi’s administration came to power in 2014. The men were released, even though footage of the murder continues to be circulated and watched online.

Still earlier in the year, in another state, another group of murderers of another Muslim enjoyed front-row seats in the election rally of the state’s chief minister. This same minister has in the last few weeks given his state’s police full reign to detain, injure, and kill Muslims who participate in the anti-Citizenship Amendment Act protests.

Nothing inspires me more than expressions of interfaith solidarity. Here, Hindus and Sikhs form a human chain, so that that their Muslim brothers can pray during protests against India's anti-Muslim #CitizenshipAmendmentAct. pic.twitter.com/VdUbGccYed

— CJ Werleman (@cjwerleman) December 19, 2019

More recently, the Supreme Court released on bail fourteen of the convicts charged with burning alive 33 Muslims during the 2002 state-sanctioned pogrom in Gujarat, in which thousands of Muslims were killed, brutalized, raped, and burned while hundreds of thousands others were displaced.

The convicts were ordered to do spiritual and social service. And the chief minister who oversaw the 2002 massacre in Gujarat is now India’s prime minister. What are they trying to tell us? Whose lives are worth protecting, and whose are not?

With every subtle and not so subtle celebration and sheltering of the murderers of Muslims and of those who dare to think and resist, the government is telling us who is safe and who will never be in this country.

Nation Rises Up

The message couldn’t be clearer: the government and police are here to serve the state first and citizens second, and only some of the citizens. When the leaders pledge that the Citizenship Amendment Act will not affect citizens, the terrifying subtext of that assurance is that the act will affect only those that don’t fit within the leaders’ limited and intolerant idea of India.

Their idea of India is too narrow to define the country’s brilliant multitude. They want India and its 1.3 billion citizens to be unipolar, unicolored, and monolinguistic, where one religion prevails.

With their different actions, India’s ruling party is telling that only those following certain faith, holding certain political views, wearing certain clothes, and speaking a certain tongue will be tolerated.

Some terror will be celebrated, while those that don’t fit in the ruling elite’s picture of India will be conveniently branded as terrorists. Media that align with the government’s beliefs will be tolerated, and others will be stifled.

But just as the state is showing its astounding failure to serve all its citizens, the nation is rising up to the challenge. With every protest art, protest song, and protest poetry, India is bursting from within, exhibiting the full range of what it is capable of.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Saheli Khastagir

Saheli Khastagir

Development consultant and researcher. Over the last 6 years, Khastagir has undertaken development research, M&E, and fund-raising assignments on a wide range of subjects including education, labor, child protection, youth employment, health and sanitation in South Asia and the Middle East

Related Posts

Rescue workers search for survivors in the debris of a collapsed building in Mahad, India on Tuesday. AFP
World

‘Like a House of Cards:’ Building Collapses in India, Killing 11

by Anya Ruppert
August 26, 2020
A woman holds a sign during a rally to mark Juneteenth on June 19, 2020, in San Francisco
Opinion

India’s Caste System Is Criticized but America’s Class System Is No Better

by Priya Harindranathan
August 21, 2020
Pakistan's Prime Minister Imran Khan speaks at a rally in Muzaffarabad on September 13, 2019. Photo: Aamir Qureshi/AFP.
World

Pakistan PM Khan Slams ‘Oppressor’ India on Kashmir Anniversary

by Staff Writer
August 5, 2020
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi gestures during his victory speech at the BJP headquarters in New Delhi
Opinion

India and Pakistan’s Divergent Political Paths Are Converging

by Saad Hafiz
August 4, 2020
Indians wear face masks
World

Delhi Virus Cases Dip but More Indian States Lock Down

by Staff Writer
July 22, 2020
US President Donald Trump speaks as he departs the White House, on May 5, 2020, in Washington, DC en route to Arizona, where he will tour a mask factory and hold a roundtable on Native American issues
Opinion

A Cult of Personality Can Derail Democracy

by Saad Hafiz
July 15, 2020
Next Post
Yemen to Become World’s Poorest Country if War Continues: UN

NGOs Warn France Over Suspected Arms Shipment to Saudi Arabia

Kashmiri protestors clash with Indian police in Srinagar

Kashmir: Six Months of Utter Misery

Recommended

Egyptian journalist Solafa Magdy (R) and her photojournalist husband Hossam El-Sayed

Egypt Frees Journalist Couple After Jail Time

April 14, 2021
Iranian flag

After Natanz Blast, Iran Vows to Ramp Up Uranium Enrichment

April 13, 2021
A candlelight vigil in Garden Grove, California, after the shooting that left eight people dead in Atlanta, including six Asian women

American Nightmare: The Asian-American Experience

April 13, 2021
The hotel in Vienna that hosted talks over the Iran nuclear deal in February 2016.

EU ‘Rejects Any Attempts’ to Undermine Iran Nuclear Talks

April 12, 2021
Prince Philip and Queen Elizabeth

Too Much? UK TV Viewers Complain About Prince Philip Coverage

April 10, 2021
US Capitol building

US Congress to Study Slavery Reparations Amid Racial Reckoning

April 9, 2021

Opinion

A candlelight vigil in Garden Grove, California, after the shooting that left eight people dead in Atlanta, including six Asian women

American Nightmare: The Asian-American Experience

April 13, 2021
Arkansas Governor Asa Hutchinson delivers a speech, 2016

The Hippocratic Oath Stops at the Arkansas Border

April 8, 2021
Erdogan Threatens to Open Europe Gates for Refugees

Turkey’s Latest Crackdown Spells Dangerous New Normal for Human Rights Defenders

March 29, 2021
President Biden speaks about the Colorado shootings at the White House.

US Gun Violence: Biden, You Need to Do Something. Now

March 26, 2021
COVID Stimulus Checks: Does Victory Include Abandoning the Most Vulnerable?

COVID Stimulus Checks: Does Victory Include Abandoning the Most Vulnerable?

March 25, 2021
A couple wearing facemasks to prevent the spread of coronavirus watch the sunset from Elysian Park in Los Angeles, California, last month.

Why We Should Expect a Roaring ’20s 2.0 for Our New Normal

March 16, 2021
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post