• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Sunday, January 17, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

Who’s First-in-Line for the Vaccine? A Classic Problem in Medical Ethics

Edward C. Halperin by Edward C. Halperin
12/30/20
in Featured, Opinion
Volunteers are given the Moderna vaccine on August 5, 2020, in Detroit, Michigan.

Volunteers are given the Moderna vaccine on August 5, 2020, in Detroit, Michigan. Photo: Henry Ford Health System/ AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

We will all hear and read a great deal in the next few weeks regarding “Who goes first?” in the administration of COVID-19 vaccines.

When there are more people who need to be vaccinated than available stock, who decides who is first, second, and third in line? What criteria are used to make those decisions?

While these issues will be a new experience for many people, the prioritization of scarce medical resources is certainly not a new problem in medical ethics. Indeed, the opposite is the case. It is, unfortunately, a common problem.

Lifeboat Ethics

Some medical ethicists use a shorthand description for the problem of scarce medical resources: lifeboat ethics.

If there are more passengers than seats in the lifeboats when the ship starts sinking, who gets into the lifeboats first? We all remember the typical Hollywood movie cry “Women and children first!” It’s certainly not a hypothetical shorthand description.

In 1841, for example, the American ship William Brown, bound to Philadelphia from Liverpool, struck an iceberg in the North Atlantic and began to sink. Crew members in one of the lifeboats, overcrowded and floundering in rough seas, threw 16 people overboard into the freezing waters. First mate Alexander William Holmes was found guilty of manslaughter and sentenced to six months in prison and a $20 fine.

Medical Ethics

When I was a young doctor specializing in cancer care in the early 1980s, I worked under the supervision of a somewhat irascible medical school professor who would say to me “I don’t know what the point is of teaching courses in medical ethics. Medical ethics is just common sense.”

I knew he was wrong, but it took me more than three decades in medical practice before I figured out why. The problem is not getting a system of ethics to make sense. Lots of ethical systems can be constructed to have an internally consistent logic. The problem is for a society to determine what is common. What are our shared societal values about justice and equity which determine the right course of action?

A tray of trial COVID-19 vaccines
A tray of trial COVID-19 vaccines. Photo: Mladen Antonov/AFP

A physician has a duty to do all that they can for the benefit of their patient. They are physicians caring for a person — not serving the needs of the state. Decisions about the allocation of scarce resources are best made by social consensus vested in societal institutions as long as those decisions are transparent, widely discussed, and subject to regular review.

Four Principles of Ethics

There are four principles of ethics we can use as tools when deciding who gets a scarce resource, including a vaccine.

The first is the degree of benefit. Are some people much more likely to benefit than others? Will an elderly individual with serious underlying medical conditions in a nursing home be more likely to benefit from immediate vaccination than, say, a young person with no underlying medical conditions living and working at home? If the answer is “yes” then the elderly person gets in line first.

79-year-old Dublin woman called Annie set to be the first person in the Republic to receive the COVID-19 vaccine.

Others receiving the jab today include: a junior doc, an ICU nurse, a Covid ward nurse and an allied health professional.#COVID19

— Richard Chambers (@newschambers) December 29, 2020

The second is the likelihood that a benefit will occur. We prioritize sure things over long shots.

The third is the duration of the benefit. We prefer long term over short term benefits.

Finally, we think about how many people will benefit. For example, if you vaccinate an ICU nurse then it is likely that both the nurse and their current and future patients will benefit. If you vaccinate a hermit living alone in a hut in the woods, then no one else may benefit. 

Who Goes First?

It’s not appropriate to hand out scarce medical resources based on ability to pay, anyone’s personal concept of social worth, or a person’s past use of medical resources. What is appropriate when deciding “Who goes first” for a vaccine program? It is to use a rational way of establishing tiers of benefit.

The United Kingdom’s Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation, for example, created a priority list for COVID-19 vaccination which gives preference to elderly individuals in nursing homes and their caregivers, frontline health and social care workers, and the clinically most vulnerable. Ultimately, however, one would expect the health care infrastructure to manufacture adequate stocks of vaccine so that, over time, the need to prioritize becomes moot.

How do we decide “What are our common values?” for the allocation of vaccines?

We can turn to the advice of Thomas Jefferson: “I know of no safe depository of the ultimate power of society but the people themselves; and if we think them not enlightened enough to exercise their control with a wholesome discretion, the remedy is not to take it from them, but to inform their discretion.”

At the end of the day “Who goes first?” for vaccination is an expression of our common values.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Edward C. Halperin

Edward C. Halperin

Teaches history of medicine at New York Medical College in Valhalla NY where he serves as the college’s Chancellor and CEO. This editorial represents his personal opinion and not that of the college.

Related Posts

Pedestrians wait to cross a street in Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpur on October 7, 2020.
Democracy at Risk

Malaysia Declares Virus Emergency, Suspends Parliament

by Staff Writer
January 12, 2021
COVID-19 has already caused over 346,000 deaths in the US.
National

New Year Arrives With US Hitting 20 Million Covid Cases

by Staff Writer
January 1, 2021
A National Basketball Association logo.
National

NBA to Require Players to Wear Covid Tracking Devices

by Staff Writer
January 1, 2021
Zhang Zhan has been sentenced to four years in prison in a Shanghai court.
Media Freedom

Chinese Citizen Journalist Jailed for Four Years for Wuhan Virus Reporting

by Staff Writer
December 28, 2020
Hydroxychloroquine
World

Three Women Scientists Speak Out Against Cyberbullying

by Staff Writer
December 24, 2020
Coronavirus in France
World

France Rewards Frontline Covid Workers With Citizenship

by Staff Writer
December 22, 2020
Next Post
Police attempt to stop journalists from recording footage outside the Shanghai Pudong New District People’s Court, where Chinese citizen journalist Zhang Zhan was on trial.

EU Demands China Release Citizen Journalist Zhang Zhan

Pro-choice activists celebrate after the Senate approved a bill to legalize abortion outside the Congress in Buenos Aires on December 30.

Argentines Celebrate as Senate Passes Landmark Abortion Bill

Recommended

The filing was submitted by Justice Department lawyers on Thursday, January 14.

US Rioters Sought to ‘Capture and Assassinate’ Lawmakers at Capitol: Prosecutors

January 15, 2021
Biden proposes raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour.

Biden Unveils $1.9 Tn Economic Plan as US Recovery Buckles

January 14, 2021
Senegalese soldiers from the UN peacekeeping mission in Mali, MINUSMA, July 24, 2019.

UN Peacekeeper Killed in Mali, Seven Wounded: Spokesman

January 13, 2021
President Donald Trump in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House.

Threatening Democracy: The Choice Between Progress and Extremism Has Never Been So Clear

January 13, 2021
Jake Angeli speaks to a US Capitol Police officer.

American Democracy Will Prevail

January 13, 2021
People march against climate change in Bordeaux, southwestern France, on October 13, 2018.

NGOs Accuse France of Climate Inaction in Landmark Court Case

January 13, 2021

Opinion

President Donald Trump in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House.

Threatening Democracy: The Choice Between Progress and Extremism Has Never Been So Clear

January 13, 2021
Jake Angeli speaks to a US Capitol Police officer.

American Democracy Will Prevail

January 13, 2021
Pro-Trump protester in front of Capitol Hill.

Riots at Capitol Hill: Darkness Before the Dawn?

January 8, 2021
Volunteers are given the Moderna vaccine on August 5, 2020, in Detroit, Michigan.

Who’s First-in-Line for the Vaccine? A Classic Problem in Medical Ethics

December 30, 2020
A sorghum farmer inspects her small grains crop thriving in the dry conditions in March in the Mutoko rural area of Zimbabwe

The 10-Year Food Systems Revolution Must Start Now

December 22, 2020
Playing the Un-Naming Game in New York Is Harder Than It Seems

Pandenomics: The High Cost of Living While Undocumented in the United States

December 22, 2020
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post