• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Thursday, January 26, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Featured

Gender Discrimination: Still Long Road Ahead

Heath Fogg Davis by Heath Fogg Davis
08/06/17
in Featured, Opinion
Gender Discrimination: Still Long Road Ahead
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Oregon and D.C. now allow their residents to choose a third “nonbinary” X sex marker on their driver’s licenses. California is poised to go even further and add a nonbinary gender designation not only to driver’s licenses but to birth certificates, too.

These are bold moves, but they won’t address the gender identity discrimination that many transgender and gender non-conforming people face when it comes to government-issued IDs. This new third gender option leaves intact the real source of gender identity discrimination: sex markers, themselves. We should get rid of sex-markers on government-issued IDs altogether.

This is a radical proposal, but one grounded in liberal legal doctrine. U.S. Courts have said that when the government or a “state actor” invokes sex or gender in a policy, it must show that the relationship between the sex classification a legitimate government goal is not only rational but also “substantial.” This is the intermediate standard of judicial review that falls somewhere below the “strict scrutiny” that states must meet when they use race in a policy and the basic rational relationship test that is a catchall for other identities such as age. Put another way: Could the state actor (i.e., a DMV) achieve the legitimate goal some other way without invoking gender?

Not only do sex-marked IDs fail intermediate judicial review, but they also fail the rational relationship test because they are not even rationally related to a legitimate government goal. There are two main legitimate goals that state governments aim to achieve by issuing driver’s licenses: 1. Standardize safe driving practices 2. To verify our personal identities when it comes to enforcing safe driving practices. Both of these goals are important. But sex markers are not necessary for achieving them. The government can and should verify our personal identities by other means. Photos, although imperfect, are rationally related to personal identity verification, as are some forms of biometrics such as fingerprints and irises.

Transgender experience tells us that the sex identities we are assigned to at birth are personally changeable over the course of our lifetimes, and intersex experience tells us that genital inspection at birth does not always yield the dyadic sex designations of male or female. Moreover, some people identify as both male and female, or neither. Indeed, Oregon’s decision to add an X for non-binary marker option was inspired by a nonbinary person’s request for a classificatory alternative to M or F on their driver’s license. Before making this request Jamie Shupe had petitioned a court to be legally recognized as “non-binary,” and been granted this legal recognition.

What are the policy implications of such legal recognition? A third sex category is one possibility. Some other countries have adopted this accommodation approach. In Canada, my home province of Ontario offers a third “nonbinary” X sex markers on its driver’s licenses. In 2013, Australia passed legislation that added a third sex marker option of “X” in addition to “M” or “F” to its passports. X represents the sex category of “indeterminate,” and is only available to Australians who were born with intersex conditions, and transgender Australians who can produce a “letter of support” from a physician. Bangladesh added a similar third sex marker option of “other” to its passports in 2013, and India passed legislation in 2005 that added a third sex marker option of “E” that stands for a eunuch. In 2013, Germany gave intersex adults, but not transgender adults, the third option of “X” on both their passports and birth certificates. Germany’s law also gives the parents of intersex infants the option of leaving the sex designation on their children’s birth certificate blank.

These reforms are progressive to the extent that they acknowledge that our sex identities are personally changeable and not always dyadic. This could be helpful in terms of educating the broader public about the existence of transgender, intersex, and nonbinary people. If this became a bureaucratic norm, then administrative agents would come to expect that some people’s identity documents would have a third sex identity marker. But in the meantime, there are non-binary people who will feel stigmatized by having an X on their driver’s license. Not all nonbinary people seek or welcome such public disclosure. So the law won’t help all non-binary Oregonians and DC residents; only those who wish to be seen by police officers and store clerks as nonbinary.

The law is being touted as something that will help transgender people. But Oregon and DC already allow transgender people to change their legal sex classification from male to female or female to male, as do all fifty states. Both this assimilation and the accommodation approach of adding a third non-binary gender option fail to get to the root of gender identity discrimination, and indeed many other forms of sexism. For this, we need to rethink our use of sex-classification policies in the first.

The removal of sex markers from government-issued IDs would not end all sexism, but it would spark cultural reform. It would send a strong message to all of us that a person’s sex classification is irrelevant to most public transactions, including getting pulled over for a traffic ticket and purchasing beer.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Heath Fogg Davis

Heath Fogg Davis

Heath Fogg Davis is Associate Professor of Political Science at Temple University, and was recently appointed to Philadelphia’s Mayoral Commission on LGBT Affairs. He is the author of Beyond Trans: Does Gender Matter? (New York University Press).

Related Posts

The Supreme Court of the United States.
National

US Supreme Court to Take on LBGTQ Rights in the Workplace

by Staff Writer
October 8, 2019
Transgender Army veteran Tanya Walker speaks to protesters in Times Square near a military recruitment centre
Opinion

Trump Administration’s Arbitrary and Regressive Proposal to Redefine Gender

by John H. Turco
October 30, 2018
A woman applies lipstick in front of a shelf of makeup
Opinion

Look Good for Me: Sex and Gender Oppression in Beauty Industry

by Jaden Yocom and Lilly Thacker
October 17, 2018
Transgender, military, serve
National

Advocacy Groups: Killings of Transgender People Increase in US

by Staff Writer with AP
November 17, 2017
Next Post
Syrian War Exposes Limits of Iran’s Air Power

Syrian War Exposes Limits of Iran's Air Power

McMaster Trump

Trump Defends McMaster From Right-Wing Attacks

Please login to join discussion

Recommended

The Doomsday Clock reads 100 seconds to midnight, a decision made by The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, during an announcement at the National Press Club in Washington, DC on January 23, 2020

‘Doomsday Clock’ Moves Closest Ever to Midnight

January 25, 2023
Police work near the scene of a mass shooting in Monterey Park, California

California Lunar New Year Mass Shooter Dead, Motive Unclear: Police

January 23, 2023
New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern

Race on To Replace Ardern as New Zealand Prime Minister

January 20, 2023
Pfizer logo and vaccines

Pfizer to Sell More Drugs at Cost to Poor Nations

January 18, 2023
Rescuers inspect the wreckage at the site of a Yeti Airlines plane crash in Pokhara, Nepal

At Least 67 Killed in Nepal Plane Crash

January 16, 2023
George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023

Opinion

George Santos from the 3rd Congressional district of New York

George Santos for Speaker!

January 16, 2023
Commuters waiting for buses in Metro Manila. Philippines

Eight Billion and Counting…

November 29, 2022
Mahsa Amini protests

Imagining a Free Iran

October 24, 2022
Vladimir Putin

How 18th Century International Law Clarifies the Situation in Ukraine

September 29, 2022
Vladimir Putin

Falling for Putin

September 15, 2022
US President Donald Trump

Donald Trump Thanks You for Your Sacrifice

August 17, 2022
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post