• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Monday, January 25, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

UK Ruling on Parliament Suspension Highlights Flaw in British Democracy

Sandy Milne by Sandy Milne
09/24/19
in Opinion
Protesters outside the UK Supreme Court yelled for parliament to be reopened after PM Johnson had suspended it in the run-up to Brexit.

Protesters outside the court yelled for parliament to be reopened. Photo: Tolga Akmen, AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

“The question arises in circumstances which have never arisen before and are unlikely to arise again. It is a one-off,” said Lady Hale, President of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom, in handing down yesterday’s decision to declare the controversial suspension of parliament in the run-up to Brexit unlawful.

Unlikely to arise again, yes – especially given the Court’s thinly-veiled contempt for the suggestion that the exercise of this particular power was not justiciable. But a holistic view of the historical evolution of the Westminster system – and the fact that this bizarre set of circumstances should even come before a court of law in the first place – highlights a crack in the fundamental set of rules governing British politics today.

A “one-off”? Wishful thinking perhaps.

UK Supreme Court: "The Court is bound to conclude, therefore, that the decision to advise Her Majesty to prorogue parliament was unlawful." pic.twitter.com/Yvc5N0nVxR

— euronews (@euronews) September 24, 2019

Unlike in the United States and most of continental Europe, where a set of black-letter policies prescriptively addresses congressional norms and boundaries of power, legislative and executive actors in Britain find their “rulebook” somewhere amongst a tangled web of unwritten conventions, traditions, social consensus, and case law.

No formal constitution exists; instead, royal prerogative is vested in the Queen, who is expected to act at the discretion of the sitting prime minister (a position you won’t find listed in any actual set of parliamentary rules), and who is expected to act in accordance with a vaguely-defined set of ethical and professional conventions.

Colonial offshoots, such as Australia and Canada, often go one step further, adding a Governor-General to represent the Queen in this mix. Strangely enough, it would seem as though a judge also fits in at some point now, although this author wouldn’t profess to know where.

‘Ceremonial’ Powers

Prorogation has received an unexpected shove into the limelight this week, but what other powers could but usually aren’t enacted as a result of this historical hangover? 

Almost all of the truly terrifying ones, it turns out. Not to suggest that declarations of war might one day come again from Buckingham rather than Westminster, it is nevertheless worth remembering that these so-called ceremonial powers were invoked in the relatively unceremonious dumping of Australian Prime Minister Gough Whitlam in 1975, at the behest of the then Governor-General John Kerr.

Thanks to imperial escapades in the 18th century, the British monarchy reserves the powers to do just about anything and everything; from blocking budgets in the Bahamas to pardoning pirates in Papua New Guinea.

Republican movements in a number of Commonwealth countries have leaned on this argument, in some shape or another, for years. The suggestion that these powers be formally codified and attributed to a democratically-elected body, however, is not tantamount to a call for revolution and could actually be said to intersect with an idealistic view of the representative monarchy. There’s nothing to say, for example, that these powers couldn’t be defined such that their enactment at the will of the royal representative also necessarily depends on obtaining Parliamentary approval.

Abuse of Power

The often-touted theory goes that Westminster systems – the British model, in particular – have refrained from adopting strict sets of rules about the exercise of power to remain flexible to changes in societal norms over time. In retrospect, this view certainly holds value over the course of the 20th century, as Commonwealth nations developed from colonial outposts into independent states, and as our understanding of the values underpinning representative democracies matured and refined.

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson
UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson. Photo: Andy Buchanan, AFP

But in today’s world, few would argue that certain situations can be said to be in line with democratic ideals. Take, for example, the appointment of Governors-General in both Australia and Canada (which is the choice of the British monarch at law, but of the Prime Minister in practice).

Writing on the interaction between these powers and the British “constitution” more broadly, historian Robert Saunders suggests, “It relies on trust and a common commitment to its unwritten rules. That has allowed it to adapt and evolve, but leaves it dangerously vulnerable to the abuse of power.”

Taking even the most cursory of glances through Supreme Court President Lady Hale’s judgment, it seems apparent that she would agree.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Sandy Milne

Sandy Milne

Published author and legal academic currently teaching in Tokyo, Japan. He holds an LLB from Curtin University (Western Australia)/Ghent University (Belgium), and his writings focus on international law and its bearing on world affairs

Related Posts

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson.
National

UK Slams ‘Disgraceful Scenes’ at Capitol by Trump Supporters

by Staff Writer
January 6, 2021
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson
World

Britain Holds Crisis Meeting Over Virus Travel Ban

by Staff Writer
December 21, 2020
Conversion therapy has affected hundreds of thousands of individuals in the US.
World

More Than 300 Religious Leaders Urge Ban on ‘Conversion Therapy’

by Staff Writer
December 16, 2020
Cyber attack
World

Russia Dismisses Hacking Allegations as ‘Russophobia’

by Staff Writer
October 20, 2020
China tests citizens for coronavirus.
World

China Tests Entire City for Virus as WHO Slams Herd Immunity Idea

by Staff Writer
October 13, 2020
A woman in a face mask at the King's Cross Station, London.
Opinion

The UK’s Woeful Response to the Coronavirus

by Ben Williams
October 5, 2020
Next Post
An iceberg captured on camera during a 30-day mission in 2012 to map areas of the Arctic aboard the NOAA Ship Fairweather.

Humanity Must Rescue Oceans to Rescue Itself, UN Warns

US President Donald Trump.

Impeachment: 'Transcript' Shows Trump Asked Ukraine to Probe Rival Biden

Recommended

Extreme weather led to floods in Indonesia in 2018.

480,000 Killed by Extreme Weather This Century: Analysis

January 25, 2021
Russian police arresting protesters in Moscow as they demonstrate in support of Alexey Navalny.

Russia Police Violence in Spotlight After 3,500 Protesters Detained

January 24, 2021
A woman leaves after receiving the Covid-19 shot at the Al-Abbas Islamic Centre, which has been converted into a temporary vaccination center in Birmingham.

UK Imams Mobilize to Counter Covid Vaccine Disinformation

January 22, 2021
The EU's corruption watchdog has been investigating Frontex.

EU’s Frontex Says ‘No Evidence’ of Illegal Migrant Pushbacks

January 21, 2021
As members of the Covax facility, the poorest nations are expecting their first doses in February.

Covax: The Global Plan to Share Covid Vaccines

January 21, 2021
Vatican has vaccinated 25 people experiencing homelessness against the coronavirus.

Vatican Vaccinates Homeless Against Coronavirus

January 20, 2021

Opinion

President Donald Trump sits alongside Kellyanne Conway, counselor to the president, during a meeting on the opioid epidemic in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on June 12, 2019.

Queen Rat Conway Swims for Safe Harbor: Too Little Too Late?

January 20, 2021
Medical personnel is given the Pfizer-Biontech Covid-19 corona virus vaccine at the Favoriten Clinic in Vienna, Austria, on December 27, 2020

The Vaccine Battle Highlights the Need to Communicate Science

January 20, 2021
President Donald Trump in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House.

Threatening Democracy: The Choice Between Progress and Extremism Has Never Been So Clear

January 13, 2021
Jake Angeli speaks to a US Capitol Police officer.

American Democracy Will Prevail

January 13, 2021
Pro-Trump protester in front of Capitol Hill.

Riots at Capitol Hill: Darkness Before the Dawn?

January 8, 2021
Volunteers are given the Moderna vaccine on August 5, 2020, in Detroit, Michigan.

Who’s First-in-Line for the Vaccine? A Classic Problem in Medical Ethics

December 30, 2020
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post