• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Tuesday, August 16, 2022
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Italy’s New Government: Tectonic Shift or More of the Same?

Zsofia Barta by Zsofia Barta
06/22/18
in Opinion
League leader Matteo Salvini

Matteo Salvini, leader of the anti-immigrant League, has already toned down his criticism of the euro. Photo: Tony Gentile, Reuters

45
SHARES
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Many see the results of Italy’s elections in March as very bad news for Europe. First, the results dashed the hope (fueled by recent elections in the Netherlands, France and Germany) that “old Europe” might be able to resist the rise of anti-establishment and populist forces that caused political upheaval elsewhere. With the dissident Five Star Movement (M5S) coming in as the indisputable winner at 33 percent of the vote and the far-right League third at 17 percent, Italians clearly handed majority to forces outside of the political mainstream.

Second, these winners voiced critical opinions about the value of European monetary integration for Italy. Could their coming to power threaten the exit of a founding member and one of the Eurozone’s largest economies?

Last, but not least, these parties focused their electoral promises on increasing transfers and cutting taxes, which are potentially dangerous propositions in a country as indebted as Italy. If investors lose confidence in Italy’s willingness and ability to service its debt (as they did in late 2011, when the European Central Bank had to intervene to stop the surge of the yields on Italian bonds), an Italian debt crisis could wreak havoc in all of Europe’s economies. Participation of the runner-up Democratic Party in the government might have alleviated some of these concerns, but the government that was finally sworn in at the beginning of this month consists of just M5S and the League.

As ominous as this situation might seem, the Italy under the new M5S-the League government is not forebodingly different from the Italy that has been part of the progressively deeper economic and political integration of Europe since the late 1970s.

Outsiders with Populist Tinge

The outcome of the recent elections is similar to the one in 1994. Back then, Italy elected a coalition of political outsiders with a populist tinge, consisting of Forza Italia, the National Alliance and the League, out of frustration with old elites. However, two years later, Italians returned to the ballot box only to choose a coalition very much in line with European centrism (led by the predecessors of the Democratic Party). This gave rise to a relatively regular alternation in power between the populist center-right and the Europeanist center-left between 1994 and 2018. During this time, Italy became a member of the Eurozone and had few conflicts with the European Council or Commission.

Although the rhetoric of the new populist coalition is arguably somewhat harsher than that of the populists of the 1990s and 2000s (especially the League’s anti-immigration stance, made more salient by the immigration crisis of the past three years), there is at this point little reason to assume that Italians are turning away from democracy and European values for good.

Doubts about Italy’s place in European economic integration do not originate with the current coalition, either. As early as the time of the creation of the European Monetary System in 1978, Italian policymakers were wary of fixing the exchange rate of the lira to other European currencies for fear of damaging economic competitiveness and had to be strong-armed by their European partners into joining.

Indeed, Italy struggled with keeping parity throughout the 1980s, devaluing the lira several times until it fell out the system definitively in 1992. When it came to joining the euro, even the Europeanist center-left dithered until the very last moment, weighing the benefits of lower financing costs on government debt against the potentially prohibitive cost of loss of economic competitiveness.

Toning Down Criticism

Emphasizing these economic costs of the euro was obviously politically expedient for the League and M5S during the campaign against the Democratic Party but in government, they too, have to be mindful of the implications for the costs of government debt. As a result, the League’s leader Matteo Salvini has already toned down his criticism of the euro, saying that while joining was a bad idea, the costs of leaving would be too high.

Tax Cuts and Increased Spending

The parallels with the past four decades are possibly the strongest when it comes to the new coalition’s plans to cut taxes while committing large sums to maintaining the livelihoods of broad sections of the population dependent on the state.

Keeping tax pressure low (whether by condoning tax evasion or by explicitly cutting rates) to woo the more prosperous Northerners has been the electoral strategy of every center-right government, from the Christian Democrat-led government of the First Republic to the populist coalitions of the Second, as has been the catering to the dependents of the state in the less prosperous South by a combination of transfers, subsidies and public employment.

Although the design of the new coalition’s policies is much more overt and institutionalized than the often-obfuscated measures previous center-right forces took (the League proposes a flat tax, while M5S wants to introduce a universal basic income scheme, and both endorse a point-based pension reform), the target constituencies and the fiscal effects are the same.

The deficits that such contradictory fiscal policies generate are obviously unsustainable in the long run. It is impossible to say, however, how likely they are to spook markets in the short term. With debt at record levels, the sensitivity of investors might be high. However, if interest rates stayed as low as now, even this larger debt stock would generate lower interest costs (and leave more room for primary deficits) than under previous center-right coalitions that pursued the same policies without triggering market panic.

Yields did surge in the past weeks suggesting that the new government needs to tread carefully, but experience has shown that in the face of threatening market reactions, governments do back down.

In sum, Italy’s new government coalition is symptomatic of many of Italy’s long-term woes: the persisting conflicts of interest between the tax-tired North and the transfer-hungry South; the constraints of euro membership on competitiveness hindering economic recovery; and the resultant rejection by voters of parties that deliver no economic prosperity in return for pains of reform. In the short term, however, there is no reason to despair.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
Share45Tweet
Zsofia Barta

Zsofia Barta

Assistant Professor of Comparative Public Policy at the University at Albany

Related Posts

migrants
Refugees

Hundreds of Rescued Migrants Disembark in Italy’s Sicily

by Staff Writer
December 29, 2021
migrants
Refugees

NGO Ship Carrying 800 Migrants Pleads for Safe Port

by Staff Writer
November 5, 2021
Migrants fleeing Libyan waters to settle in Europe
Refugees

Over 1,400 Migrants Land on Italy’s Lampedusa Island

by Staff Writer
May 10, 2021
Vatican has vaccinated 25 people experiencing homelessness against the coronavirus.
World

Vatican Vaccinates Homeless Against Coronavirus

by Staff Writer
January 20, 2021
A line for Covid-19 screening at a testing station set up at Fiumicino airport, near Rome.
World

First ‘Covid-Tested’ Flight Lands in Rome From New York

by Staff Writer
December 9, 2020
COVID-19 Vaccine Research
World

Italy Begins Human Trials of COVID-19 Vaccine

by Alexandra Marquez
August 24, 2020
Next Post
Fans of the football team from Tibet

CONIFA World Cup: Football and Hopes for Independence

Kim Jong-Un and Donald Trump

Trump-Kim Historic Summit: What is the Way Forward?

Please login to join discussion

Recommended

Marina Ovsyannikova

Russian TV Journalist Faces Jail Time for Anti-Putin Protest

August 10, 2022
Mar-A-Lago raid

FBI Raid on Trump’s Home Ignites Political Firestorm

August 9, 2022
Ukraine nuclear plant

Ukraine Calls for De-Militarization of Occupied Nuclear Plant

August 8, 2022
Toru Kubota

Myanmar Junta Charges Japanese Journalist With Encouraging Dissent

August 4, 2022
Nancy Pelosi

Taiwan Defiant as China Readies Military Drills Over Pelosi Visit

August 3, 2022
Protesters stand with placards in front of the statue of India's independence leader Mahatma Gandhi in Parliament Square, central London, after a demonstration outside the US Embassy

Considering the Patience of Gandhi for These Troubled Times

August 5, 2022

Opinion

Protesters stand with placards in front of the statue of India's independence leader Mahatma Gandhi in Parliament Square, central London, after a demonstration outside the US Embassy

Considering the Patience of Gandhi for These Troubled Times

August 5, 2022
US President Donald Trump

Owning the Words and the Libs

June 16, 2022
Officers in Uvalde, Texas, stand outside Robb Elementary School near a makeshift memorial for the shooting victims

Child Sacrifice Makes a Comeback

June 3, 2022
A Lebanese election official stands at a polling station

New Group Threatens Lebanese Elections… and Potentially Middle East Peace

May 18, 2022
A man holding a gun

Safely Back in USA, Land of Guns and Burgers

May 2, 2022
China Muslim Uyghurs

Unfair Politicization, Corruption, and the Death of Modern Olympism

April 23, 2022
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post