• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Saturday, May 21, 2022
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Will the Meek Inherit Argentina in 2019?

Robert Haywood Scott and Kenneth Mitchell by Robert Haywood Scott and Kenneth Mitchell
04/30/19
in Opinion
Argentinian holding up the Argentina Peso, the country's currency

Argentina hikes interest rates to 60 percent - the world's highest - as the country's currency goes into freefall. Photo: Leo la Valle, AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Aristotle said, “Poverty is the parent of revolution and crime.” If so, then Argentina needs to brace itself.

In November 2015, Mauricio Macri, Argentina’s maverick president adored by Wall Street and the IMF, won a close run-off election on a tripartite platform of less political polarization, less crime, and “zero poverty in four years.” Ubiquitous zero poverty propaganda showered Macri rallies by election day.

In October, four years after Macri’s election, weary Argentines will return to the polls with poverty rates higher rather than lower and with no end in sight. What went wrong?

Export Tax Cuts and Currency Liberalization

Reckless, ideological policies began at once. Only one month after taking office, Macri decreed two fateful economic reforms: export tax cuts and currency liberalization.

Beef, wheat, and corn export taxes immediately stopped while the rate on soybeans, the country’s top cash crop, fell from 35 to 30 percent. For Macri, tax cuts proffered three benefits. First, tax cuts by lowering the domestic cost of food, the biggest item in households’ budgets, would reduce inflation, running around 25 percent when Macri took office. Second, incentivized farmers would boost economic growth allowing tax cuts to pay for themselves without adding more foreign debt. Third, tax cuts would boost dollar reserves because when farmers export, the dollars (or euros, yen, and yuan) go into the Central Bank which in turn pays farmers in pesos.

Macri knew the potential perils of full currency liberalization – Argentina did it back in January 2002 – and he bet on foreign investment pouring in to stabilize the peso and offset short-term public revenue losses from tax cuts.

#Argentina's debt is the greatest in the region, consuming an estimated 97 percent of the nation's GDP. #IMF pic.twitter.com/QrBogDDfcZ

— teleSUR English (@telesurenglish) February 13, 2019

Like Brazil, Argentina tends to borrow in dollars, a devaluing domestic currency risk that could trigger a debt spiral. Devaluation brings inflation as well, and nothing spooks Argentines and foreign investors more than rising inflation given the country’s history of hyperinflation and sovereign defaults.

In 2016, when currency controls were lifted, locals bought dollars, and foreign investors ignored positive media reports and stayed on the sidelines. In short, the seeds of the current crisis were planted. Three years later, at the start of 2019, the peso devalued 50 percent, inflation hit 47.6 percent, Macri had penned the largest IMF bailout loan on record (US$ 56.3 billion), and poverty reached 32 percent.

Optimism About 2019

Wall Street, the IMF, and Macri expressed optimism about 2019. With the prior year’s unexpected and unfortunate events (such as drought and the U.S.-China trade war) having passed, a bumper harvest on the way, and the IMF forcing Macri to reinstate export taxes, optimism seemed reasonable.

Yet, GDP contraction accelerated in the first quarter of 2019, and a new run on the peso forced the Central Bank to raise interest rates to 70 percent, crippling businesses and job creation. Poverty must increase in 2019, and short of an economic miracle, it will continue to do so in 2020.

Economic Troubles

Argentina’s current economic troubles were not inevitable. When Macri took over from Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, the country had shown its resilience after the commodity boom went bust in 2011.

Record tax collection, political stability (by Argentine standards), and government redistributions via conditional cash transfer programs permitting the poor to spend more on food, education, and health helped keep Argentina’s economy growing.

Argentina’s historic Achilles heel, low tax collections, had improved significantly up to 2015 when the country’s tax revenue-to-GDP matched Brazil’s at 32 percent. At the start of the Kirchner era in 2003, no multilateral or academic observer saw Argentina matching Brazilian tax collection – it was unthinkable.

Argentina’s 2002 sovereign default left it in international financial market exile. Isolation had some benefits. Argentina had to resolve its domestic revenue problem and get creative with stabilizing the country’s currency.

Soon after Macri became president, he settled the long-standing government debt disputes with old bondholders. Then he quickly sold tens of billions of dollars in bonds, much of it in dollars. Export tax cuts balanced against reckless bond issuance and government spending increases produced economic instability that ended in a record $56.3 billion loan from the IMF in the summer of 2018.

World Bank data on government spending as a percentage of GDP shows Macri’s first two years surpassing Kirchner’s final two years. Macri keeps propping up the peso with borrowed IMF money and without regard for Argentina’s debt burden. Wrestling the peso into submission is a fool’s errand, one the IMF is more than complicit in. Ex-IMF staffer Hector Torres writes in Project Syndicate that about 90 percent of the IMF loan ($51.2 billion) “would be disbursed before Argentina’s next presidential election in late 2019.”

Run on Peso

Soon after his election, Macri removed currency controls put into place in the wake of the commodity market bust in 2011. Known as the Cepo Cambiario, the country started limiting how much foreign currency could be exchanged for Argentine pesos. They did this to prop up the peso by restricting capital flight, which is a problem among skittish Argentines worried about inflation and instability.

President of Argentina Mauricio Macri
Argentina’s President Mauricio Macri. Photo: AFP

Once currency controls were removed, Argentines responded by exchanging Argentine pesos since this behavior was constrained for four years. The result is a run on the peso with no end in sight.

Even if Macri reinstates currency controls, he faces a steep uphill battle to get the economy growing again. He has lost considerable goodwill among his supporters, but he still has political strength, which he now needs to use to regain the country’s confidence.

Going Forward

Three potential outcomes are available to Argentina for the remainder of 2019.

First, the country could double down on the status quo and maintain the world’s highest interest rates (nearly 70 percent in April), cut public spending as negotiated with the IMF and hope the recent peso devaluation ebbs. The fact that Argentina already spent over a quarter ($15 billion) of its $57 billion IMF line of credit within a few weeks as the peso slid to historic lows suggests this is a perilous path.

Second, Argentina could dollarize following the path of Ecuador, El Salvador, Guatemala, and Panama. But these countries have small economies compared to Argentina, and more pressing, Argentines recall how fixing its currency to the U.S. dollar in the 1990s triggered an epic collapse of the economy in 2001. Dollarization slashed inflation, true, but it also produced record levels of unemployment and poverty.

Third, Argentina could reset the clock to December 2015 and reinstate currency controls, similar to Asian countries in 1997, with a forward-looking program that connects future liberalization to controlling the budget deficit.

Of these options, the last one is the most likely in 2019.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Robert Haywood Scott and Kenneth Mitchell

Robert Haywood Scott and Kenneth Mitchell

Robert Haywood Scott, III is Professor of Economics & Finance at Monmouth University. Kenneth Mitchell is Associate Professor of Political Science at Monmouth University

Related Posts

United States military
Opinion

Biden Signs Another Blank Check for the Rapacious Military Economy

by Stephen J. Lyons
January 6, 2022
Pro-choice activists celebrate after the Senate approved a bill to legalize abortion outside the Congress in Buenos Aires on December 30.
World

Argentines Celebrate as Senate Passes Landmark Abortion Bill

by Staff Writer
December 30, 2020
Argentinians celebrating a bill that legalizes abortion.
World

Amnesty Gathers 250,000 Signatures for Legal Abortion in Argentina

by Staff Writer
December 17, 2020
Diego Maradona
World

Argentines Mourn Maradona Amid Economic Crisis and Pandemic

by Staff Writer
November 26, 2020
EU Proposes Huge Aid Plan as Virus Hammers Latin America
World

Pandemic Could Push 45 Million in Latin America Into Poverty: UN

by Staff Writer
July 10, 2020
Argentina's President Alberto Fernandez
Opinion

Argentina and the IMF: Who Is at Whose Mercy?

by Robert Haywood Scott and Kenneth Mitchell
February 19, 2020
Next Post
Spain went to the polls on Sunday to vote in a general snap election

Spain Says ¡No Pasarán! and Halts the Advance of the Far Right – For Now

Venezuelan opposition activists clash with the police during a protest against the government of President Nicolas Maduro on April 6, 2017 in Caracas

Maduro Appears to Maintain Control in Venezuela Following 'Attempted Coup'

Recommended

Volkswagen logo

German Farmer Sues Volkswagen Over CO2 Emissions

May 20, 2022
Vladimir Putin

Russia Says Economy Grew 3.5 Percent in First Quarter

May 18, 2022
Mexico missing people

Over 100,000 People Reported Missing in Mexico, Data Reveals

May 17, 2022
Shireen Abu Akleh

Jerusalem Archbishop Condemns Israeli Police Raid at Journalist’s Funeral

May 16, 2022
A Lebanese election official stands at a polling station

New Group Threatens Lebanese Elections… and Potentially Middle East Peace

May 18, 2022
Israel

15 European Nations Urge Israel to Reverse Plans for More Settler Homes

May 13, 2022

Opinion

A Lebanese election official stands at a polling station

New Group Threatens Lebanese Elections… and Potentially Middle East Peace

May 18, 2022
A man holding a gun

Safely Back in USA, Land of Guns and Burgers

May 2, 2022
China Muslim Uyghurs

Unfair Politicization, Corruption, and the Death of Modern Olympism

April 23, 2022
Ukraine war

The Ukrainian Refugee Crisis and the Hierarchies of Western Compassion

April 20, 2022
Chinese leader Xi Jinping

How Wrong ‘How China Can End the War in Ukraine’ Is

April 1, 2022
Ukraine children

The War for Ukraine’s Lives and Minds

March 30, 2022
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post