• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Thursday, September 21, 2023
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

The Rise of Internet Sovereignty and the End of the World Wide Web?

Samuel Woodhams by Samuel Woodhams
04/23/19
in Opinion
Desktop showing a world wide web internet page

Photo: AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

“We know how much the internet has changed America, and we are already an open society,” said Bill Clinton in 2000. “Imagine how much it could change China. There’s no question that China has been trying to crack down on the internet. Good luck – that’s sort of like trying to nail Jello to the wall.”

In the nineteen years since Clinton made this remark, popular understandings of the web have changed beyond recognition. Once thought of as a radically free tool that traversed conventional boundaries, it is now often thought of as a space dominated by malicious private corporations, hidden surveillance tools, and a powerful force of censorship and repression.

Clinton was not entirely wrong, though; the internet has undoubtedly changed China. What he failed to predict was that in the process, China would also change the internet.

Ten years after Clinton’s now-famous quip, Chinese authorities published the white paper The Internet In China. The paper was responsible for popularizing the now ubiquitous term “internet sovereignty” and laid out its basic principles.

“Within Chinese territory, the internet is under the jurisdiction of Chinese sovereignty. The internet sovereignty of China should be respected and protected,” it said.

Importantly, the document reaffirmed China’s right to govern the internet in line with its domestic laws, claiming that “laws and regulations clearly prohibit the spread of information that contains content subverting state power, undermining national unity [or] infringing upon national honor and interests.”

Under the doctrine of internet sovereignty, these laws – which were originally applied to traditional media forms – became equally applicable to content online. Unsurprisingly, the term has since proved an important means of justifying China’s “Great Firewall,” which is the world’s most advanced digital censorship apparatus.

Internet Sovereignty Around the World

Since 2010, the term has gained currency throughout much of the world and has been adopted by several states looking to control the dissemination of information online. In the process, the world wide web has fractured into a series of state-wide webs, each controlled in distinctive ways.

This has become particularly evident during the past year in which Russia has aggressively pursued policies aimed at controlling content online. In the past two months, the state has blocked the encrypted email service ProtonMail, approved legislation that outlaws “fake news” and introduced new legislation that seeks to establish a “Sovereign Internet.”

As James Griffiths, author of The Great Firewall of China, has said in an interview:

“That the Kremlin has succeeded in adopting the Chinese model is a sign to other countries that it is never too late to rein in their own internets, and could accelerate the adoption of such tactics that have already ramped up worldwide – with Chinese assistance – in recent years.”

As Griffiths implies, this development is not confined to Russia and China. Instead, it has become a global phenomenon and represents an important rhetorical tool used by regimes across the world who are seeking to legitimize the manipulation and restriction of digital content.

Internet usage by region, 1990-2016, according to World Bank.

As the most recent Freedom on the Net report makes clear, “as governments recognize the importance of the data flowing in and out of their countries, they are establishing new rules and barriers in the name of national sovereignty, allowing officials to control and inspect such information at will.”

China has also used internet sovereignty as a part of the expansive, multi-billion-dollar Belt and Road Initiative. As Joshua Merservey, senior analyst at Heritage Foundation, told Foreign Policy, “the Chinese are explicitly pushing this idea of internet governance. They frame it as a sovereignty issue, but what they are really talking about is the ability of a state to control the free flow of information online.”

Global Internet Governance

As internet shutdowns continue to rise in frequency across the world each year, there are fears that the growing discourse of internet sovereignty is empowering governments in regards to digital censorship.

The notion of internet sovereignty is often deployed as a distinguishing feature of internet governance outside of Europe and America. However, this analysis is incomplete in a number of ways.

Firstly, the notion of internet sovereignty and its links to state actors risks masking the very real influence held by private corporations over global internet governance. As American internet entrepreneur and academic Kalev Leetaru has written, “rather than a small set of elites in each country setting the ground rules for the internet for their respective societies, a single centralized set of elites in Silicon Valley set the rules of all countries.”

This certainly underplays the influence and power that states have in the formation of the internet in their countries. However, over-deterministic claims of internet sovereignty may also be at risk of disregarding the influence of huge commercial monopolies that traverse sovereign boundaries.

Mark Zuckerberg
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg. Photo: Josh Edelson, AFP

To develop a more nuanced and fuller understanding of how the internet is regulated and controlled across the world, the agency of both commercial and state actors must be considered.

Secondly, there is a risk of portraying internet sovereignty as a term linked only to authoritarian regimes. However, governing which aspects of the web are available to users has been the global de facto position of governments since at least the late 1990s.

In the U.K., for example, there are currently plans to introduce an age-verification system for adult content. More recently, Article 13 of the latest E.U. Copyright Law has concerned digital rights experts for its potential to censor large swathes of user content online.

Without considering how internet sovereignty is also deployed in Europe and America, it is impossible to have a complete picture of how the web is controlled and organized globally.

Finally, to hail the death of the world wide web is to misunderstand the range of widely available commercial technologies that internet users now have access to. With the rise of proxy connections and Virtual Private Networks, more people than ever before are able to bypass geo-fenced content while remaining anonymous online.

Improving Digital Rights Advocacy Work 

Ultimately, any regulation of the web is likely inspired and affected by political concerns. The notion of internet sovereignty as a uniquely Chinese and Russian approach fails to identify how the same underlying principles affect Western governments.

So, although it may feel like the world wide web is quickly transforming into a series of state-wide webs, this view lacks the nuance needed for an informed debate. To complicate our understandings of how the internet is regulated, and look introspectively at how the web is governed in the West, is therefore an important step to improve digital rights advocacy work across the globe.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Samuel Woodhams

Samuel Woodhams

Freelance journalist and researcher at Top10VPN.com, a digital privacy group and VPN review website. He is interested in global debates surrounding the future of the internet and identifying trends in digital authoritarianism, repression, and disinformation

Related Posts

An elderly woman pulls a trolley bag past a destroyed building in Bakhmut in Ukraine's Donetsk
World

Sweden Pledges Over $500M to Rebuild Ukraine

by Staff Writer
July 17, 2023
People visit the World Artificial Intelligence Conference (WAIC) in Shanghai
World

China Unveils New Operating System Amid US Tensions

by Staff Writer
July 6, 2023
Ursula von der Leyen
World

EU Asks Member States for €50B to Support Ukraine

by Staff Writer
June 20, 2023
Russian-Held City ‘Flooded’ After Dam Breach
World

Russian-Held City ‘Flooded’ After Dam Breach

by Staff Writer
June 6, 2023
A man holds US, Taiwan flags
Business

US and Taiwan Ink Trade Deal as China Issues Warning

by Staff Writer
June 2, 2023
Military hardware rolls through Dvortsovaya Square during a Victory Day military parade in central Saint Petersburg
National

Pressing Russia, US Shares Nuclear Warhead Data Under Treaty

by Staff Writer
May 16, 2023
Next Post
The Earth and the moon pictured from near-Earth orbit.

A New Great Age of Space Exploration?

US President Donald Trump

Trump and Mueller Investigation: to Impeach or Not to Impeach

Recommended

Man holding up a colored LGBT flag

France Sets Up Embassy Fund to Defend LGBTQ Rights

September 19, 2023
US Authorities Seize Artworks Allegedly Stolen by Nazis

US Authorities Seize Artworks Allegedly Stolen by Nazis

September 19, 2023
Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida speaks during a news conference

Japan PM to Replace Foreign and Defense Ministers: Reports

September 12, 2023
A man walks with his belongings through the rubble in an alleyway in the earthquake-damaged old city in Marrakesh on September 9, 2023

Morocco Quake Death Toll Passes 2,000: Ministry

September 10, 2023
Pro-Trump protester in front of Capitol Hill.

The Ominous (and Irresponsible) Chatter of a Civil War 

September 4, 2023
Police at the site of one of two explosions in Gothenburg

Sweden Rocked by Four Blasts in One Night

August 31, 2023

Opinion

Pro-Trump protester in front of Capitol Hill.

The Ominous (and Irresponsible) Chatter of a Civil War 

September 4, 2023
A bamboo-based design raises family homes safely above water levels to cope with raising water levels in Bangladesh.

The West Owes Climate Refugees Reparations Now

August 14, 2023
President Donald Trump in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House.

Boxing Day Comes to South Florida

July 5, 2023
‘Deaths of Despair:’ Why Are US Suicides on the Rise?

An Inspired Choice to Lead the CDC

June 13, 2023
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis speaks at the Republican Jewish Coalition Annual Leadership Meeting in Las Vegas, Nevada, on November 19, 2022.

Florida Man Channels Benito Mussolini

June 13, 2023
Migrants waiting at the Turkish border.

Beyond Numbers: Confronting Europe’s Broken Border System

May 30, 2023
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post