• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Friday, January 22, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

The Agony of Kashmir Lies in Selfish Nationalisms

Saad Hafiz by Saad Hafiz
06/18/20
in Opinion
Kashmiri protestors clash with Indian police in Srinagar

Kashmiri protestors clash with Indian police in Srinagar in February, 2020. Photo: Tauseef Mustafa/AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

If there was a valid case for nationalism getting a bad rap, it is in Kashmir. The clashing nationalisms of India, Pakistan, and the separatists demanding independence hold the territory’s people hostage in their tight grip. It’s responsible for the heartbreaking blood and gore that Kashmiris endure daily.

Albert Einstein and the Indian poet Rabindranath Tagore saw nationalism as an infantile disease and a great menace. This fits India and Pakistan. Nationalism has bound diverse peoples within state boundaries, but it has also made inferior outsiders and evil enemies of each other. India and Pakistan have negated their shared history and culture in exchange for mutual animosity.

India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi (left) and his Pakistan counterpart Imran Khan
India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi (left) and his Pakistan counterpart Imran Khan (right). Photos: AFP

The positive view of nationalism as binding people in solidarity, fate, and common political aspirations is yet to be demonstrated in South Asia. A contest over territory and a history of violence had made matters worse. This has far-reaching consequences in Kashmir, involving two powerful armies armed with nuclear weapons in a deadly face-off. The small band of Kashmiri nationalists willing to embrace martyrdom for independence adds more fuel to the fire.

Competing Nationalisms

As a result of clashing nationalisms, India is at war its people. Pakistan wastes blood and treasure dreaming of annexing Kashmir. The separatists ruin the futures of generations of youth in a hopeless cause.

The other sad truth is that those controlling the strings in the conflict have little incentive to abandon confrontation. It would mean giving up the vast privileges gained from controlling political power, military budgets, and instruments of terror and violence.

But if we remove the ugly side of nationalism from the equation, Kashmir isn’t the seemingly intractable dispute that it is made out to be. Some sober realities about the conflict are worth considering.

Kashmir Conflict

First, India, with its enormous army and sufficient resources, can hold on to its part of Kashmir indefinitely. But it is paying an exorbitant price for its newly found muscular Hindu-only nationalism: the lengthy detention of Kashmiri leaders, restraints on political activity, torture and enforced disappearances, and attempts to change demographics. Overall, the stream-rolling over the rights of the people of Kashmir undermines Indian democracy itself.

Second, Pakistan’s strategy to bleed India in Kashmir, supposedly at low cost, has backfired. Using Kashmir as a pillar of Muslim nationalism and sustaining the decades-old jihad to drive India out of Kashmir has consigned the country to economic ruin.

Pakistani generals who control Kashmir policy, as other important national decision-making, can’t remain immune from the post-COVID-19 economic free-fall and its social consequences. Pakistan’s Kashmir policy needs a major rethink devoid of nationalist hysteria.

Lastly, the dominant discourse among separatists in parts of Kashmir and Pakistan that Kashmir’s freedom struggle and the UN-recognized right of self-determination can force India to resolve the dispute doesn’t mirror ground realities. This would require a decisive shift in international opinion against India, which not on the cards in the foreseeable future.

Several credible polls in Indian- and Pakistani-administered Kashmir reflect polarized opinions. As expected, the support for independence is very high in the primary Muslim areas at the center of the insurgency. But it is very low in predominantly Hindu areas. While people know that there are no “simple fixes” to the problem and few are optimistic about peace talks, an overwhelming majority want a solution to the dispute.

Political Compromise

There’s little doubt that it will take a seismic shift in the public consciousness to ease competing nationalisms in South Asia. Opportunistic leaders and demagogues exploit the addictive power of nationalism and the immaturity of people for their own immoral motives. It helps to paper over the massive common problems of poverty, unemployment, malnourishment, and lack of healthcare in the region.

Nevertheless, setting aside India’s governance mistakes, the constant meddling by Pakistan, and the maximalist demands of the separatists, a Kashmir solution lies in political compromise.

For instance, all parties must respect and recognize existing borders. India should restore the administrative autonomy in its part of Kashmir. In exchange, Pakistan must commit to halting terrorist groups crossing its borders to carry out attacks in India. Kashmiri separatists should drop the demand for independence. Finally, India and Pakistan must reduce the risk of war by taking steps to demilitarize the region.

Kashmir, as a tragedy with no clear end, is a blight on South Asia. It is in the hands of Indians, Pakistanis, and Kashmiris to break down the walls created by virulent nationalism and focus on bettering the region.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Saad Hafiz

Saad Hafiz

Analyst and commentator on politics, peace, and security issues

Related Posts

The Sri Lankan government forces cremation of Covid-19 victims.
World

Sri Lanka Sticks to Cremation of Muslim Covid-19 Victims Despite Uproar

by Staff Writer
January 8, 2021
A single falcon can fetch up to tens of thousands of dollars on the black market.
World

Poachers’ Paradise: Gulf Hunts Fuel Pakistan Falcon Trafficking

by Staff Writer
January 4, 2021
Conversion therapy has affected hundreds of thousands of individuals in the US.
World

More Than 300 Religious Leaders Urge Ban on ‘Conversion Therapy’

by Staff Writer
December 16, 2020
Imran Khan
Democracy at Risk

The Opposition Challenge in Pakistan

by Saad Hafiz
December 16, 2020
A protest against China’s mistreatment of Uighur Muslims
World

Over 570,000 Uighurs Involved in China Cotton Coerced Labor: Report

by Staff Writer
December 15, 2020
Municipal workers carry the coffin of an unclaimed body of a Covid-19 victim to a crematorium in Colombo, Sri Lanka.
World

Anger Grows in Sri Lanka Over Forced Muslim Virus Cremations

by Staff Writer
December 16, 2020
Next Post
Hungary's Prime Minister Viktor Orban

Hungary MPs Approve End of Controversial Emergency Virus Powers

Stop Talking About Race in a Way That Puts White Americans at Ease

Racism in US: It’s Time for People of Color to Break Their Silence

Please login to join discussion

Recommended

A woman leaves after receiving the Covid-19 shot at the Al-Abbas Islamic Centre, which has been converted into a temporary vaccination center in Birmingham.

UK Imams Mobilize to Counter Covid Vaccine Disinformation

January 22, 2021
The EU's corruption watchdog has been investigating Frontex.

EU’s Frontex Says ‘No Evidence’ of Illegal Migrant Pushbacks

January 21, 2021
As members of the Covax facility, the poorest nations are expecting their first doses in February.

Covax: The Global Plan to Share Covid Vaccines

January 21, 2021
Vatican has vaccinated 25 people experiencing homelessness against the coronavirus.

Vatican Vaccinates Homeless Against Coronavirus

January 20, 2021
President Donald Trump sits alongside Kellyanne Conway, counselor to the president, during a meeting on the opioid epidemic in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on June 12, 2019.

Queen Rat Conway Swims for Safe Harbor: Too Little Too Late?

January 20, 2021
President-elect Joe Biden and his wife Jill Biden at a COVID-19 tribute in DC on Tuesday.

In Washington, Biden Leads Tribute to 400,000 Covid Dead

January 19, 2021

Opinion

President Donald Trump sits alongside Kellyanne Conway, counselor to the president, during a meeting on the opioid epidemic in the Roosevelt Room of the White House on June 12, 2019.

Queen Rat Conway Swims for Safe Harbor: Too Little Too Late?

January 20, 2021
Medical personnel is given the Pfizer-Biontech Covid-19 corona virus vaccine at the Favoriten Clinic in Vienna, Austria, on December 27, 2020

The Vaccine Battle Highlights the Need to Communicate Science

January 20, 2021
President Donald Trump in the Brady Briefing Room of the White House.

Threatening Democracy: The Choice Between Progress and Extremism Has Never Been So Clear

January 13, 2021
Jake Angeli speaks to a US Capitol Police officer.

American Democracy Will Prevail

January 13, 2021
Pro-Trump protester in front of Capitol Hill.

Riots at Capitol Hill: Darkness Before the Dawn?

January 8, 2021
Volunteers are given the Moderna vaccine on August 5, 2020, in Detroit, Michigan.

Who’s First-in-Line for the Vaccine? A Classic Problem in Medical Ethics

December 30, 2020
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post