• About Us
  • Who Are We
  • Work With Us
Wednesday, February 24, 2021
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
The Globe Post
39 °f
New York
44 ° Fri
46 ° Sat
40 ° Sun
41 ° Mon
No Result
View All Result
The Globe Post
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

India and Pakistan’s Divergent Political Paths Are Converging

Saad Hafiz by Saad Hafiz
08/04/20
in Opinion
India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi gestures during his victory speech at the BJP headquarters in New Delhi

India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Photo: Prakash Singh/AFP

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Since emerging as independent states in August 1947, India and Pakistan have had divergent political paths. Both countries have common roots in terms of history and colonial legacy. India defied early skepticism, remained united, and mainly a secular democracy. In contrast, Pakistan struggled under military rule and with the politicization of religion.

However, based on recent events in India, the political paths of both countries appear to be converging.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi plans to attend the groundbreaking ceremony Wednesday for a Hindu temple in Ayodhya. The temple is on a disputed site in northern India where Hindu hard-liners tore down a 16th-century mosque in 1992. For Modi, who is wildly popular with his Hindu-first base, it’s another opportunity to project his nationalist credentials.

According to Modi’s allies, the date chosen for the ceremony is astrologically auspicious for Hindus. It’s expected to bring about an awakening of the feeling of Hindutva, or the Hindu way of life.

Modi’s India

The temple event is yet another sign that the Indian national identity is becoming overtly majoritarian. There was a time that India prized its inclusive identity that set aside religious, caste, class, or ethnic differences. The truth is that India has become less pluralist and tolerant since Modi came to power.

Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) enjoys virtual electoral hegemony by winning most of the Hindu vote. Hindus make up about 80 percent of the Indian electorate. But in catering to its Hindu base, the BJP is moving away from the “one state, one law, and one national community for the whole land” concept that India’s founders rightly saw as the strength of a hugely diverse country like India.

In sharp contrast to Modi, in 1951, India’s first prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru, the visionary democrat and secularist, described the ideal state as one in “which the state protects all religions, but does not favor one at the expense of others and does not itself adopt any religion as state religion.”

Chester Bowles, the then United States Ambassador to India, wrote of Nehru: “one of his greatest achievements is the creation of a secular state in which the forty-five million Muslims that choose not to go to Pakistan may live peacefully and worship as they please.”

World Biggest Democracy?

The West lauds India as the world’s largest democracy — a refreshing contrast to the string of dictatorships in Pakistan. It views free and fair elections, an independent election commission, a commitment to freedom of speech, press, and association, civil society, and thriving NGOs as the hallmarks of India’s democracy.

Yet, prominent Indians have criticized the recent actions of the Modi government. Nobel Prize-winning economist Amartya Sen described last year’s decision of the Modi government to revoke the special status of Indian Kashmir as contrary to “democratic norms.” Sen also said that the preventive detentions of Kashmiri leaders were a “throwback to the British Raj.”

Eminent academic Pratap Bhanu Mehta wrote in October that “the noose is tightening around all independent institutions in India.” Mehta mentioned “the cowardly, almost impeachable, abdication of the judiciary in the face of threats to civil liberties.” He was referring to the episode about the sedition charges (now withdrawn) against prominent writers and directors.

Law-Driven Democratic Systems

It’s important to remember that India and Pakistan have extreme levels of poverty and inequality. Political corruption and criminalization, violence based on caste, gender, and religion are major challenges for both countries. Although India has a better record than Pakistan in the treatment and protection of minorities, critics have called this record into question since the Modi government came to power.

While India has performed better on most democratic indicators than Pakistan, it must guard against the erosion of fair and uncompromising public institutions. Otherwise, it risks becoming an “illiberal democracy” or an “election-only democracy.”

Pakistan's Prime Minister Imran Khan addresses a political campaign rally
Pakistan’s Prime Minister Imran Khan addressing a political campaign rally. Photo: Farooq Naeem/AFP

Much like Pakistan, where fragile democratic institutions have been so irreversibly damaged by authoritarian rule and religious obscurantism, that support for democracy has thinned. It’s an example that India would hardly wish to emulate.

In pursuit of its grand goal to join the ranks of global superpowers, India should remain mindful of not sacrificing its past democratic successes. In Pakistan, civilian supremacy over non-democratic institutions remains the prerequisite to the advancement of genuine democracy.

Both countries must recognize that the passing forward of inclusive and law-driven democratic systems to future generations is a lofty end in itself.

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed here are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of The Globe Post.
ShareTweet
Saad Hafiz

Saad Hafiz

Analyst and commentator on politics, peace, and security issues

Related Posts

US reporter Daniel Pearl was brutally killed in 2002.
National

White House ‘Outraged’ as Pakistan Court Upholds Acquittal in Daniel Pearl Murder

by Staff Writer
January 28, 2021
A single falcon can fetch up to tens of thousands of dollars on the black market.
World

Poachers’ Paradise: Gulf Hunts Fuel Pakistan Falcon Trafficking

by Staff Writer
January 4, 2021
Imran Khan
Democracy at Risk

The Opposition Challenge in Pakistan

by Saad Hafiz
December 16, 2020
Rescue workers search for survivors in the debris of a collapsed building in Mahad, India on Tuesday. AFP
World

‘Like a House of Cards:’ Building Collapses in India, Killing 11

by Anya Ruppert
August 26, 2020
A woman holds a sign during a rally to mark Juneteenth on June 19, 2020, in San Francisco
Opinion

India’s Caste System Is Criticized but America’s Class System Is No Better

by Priya Harindranathan
August 21, 2020
Pakistan's Prime Minister Imran Khan speaks at a rally in Muzaffarabad on September 13, 2019. Photo: Aamir Qureshi/AFP.
World

Pakistan PM Khan Slams ‘Oppressor’ India on Kashmir Anniversary

by Staff Writer
August 5, 2020
Next Post
A sign in Belarus saying 'President of the Republic of Belarus'

Early Voting Begins in Stormy Belarus Presidential Election

A soldier checks the temperature of a motorist at a checkpoint before entering Manila. Photo: AFP

Philippines Reports Record Infection Rates, Orders Millions to Stay Home

Please login to join discussion

Recommended

HRW released a statement on China's increasing prosecution of Muslim minorities in Xinjiang.

China Targets Uighurs With More Prosecutions, Longer Prison Terms: HRW

February 24, 2021
Stolpersteine in Greifswald, Germany.

I Can’t Mark Where My Grandfather Is Buried, but I Want to Mark Where He Lived

February 24, 2021
An Afghan health worker administering the COVID-19 vaccine.

Afghanistan Begins Covid Vaccine Campaign Amid Surge in Violence

February 23, 2021
US President Joe Biden (L) speaks as the nation's top infectious disease expert Anthony Fauci looks on.

US Passes 500,000 Covid Deaths: Johns Hopkins Tracker

February 22, 2021
Many Rohingya refugees in Indonesia enlist the help of traffickers to cross the sea to neighboring Malaysia.

Rohingya Boat in Distress, Eight Dead: UN Refugee Agency

February 22, 2021
Republican Senator from Missouri Josh Hawley

Trump’s Acquittal and Republican Senators: Not Setting the Bar Low Enough

February 22, 2021

Opinion

Stolpersteine in Greifswald, Germany.

I Can’t Mark Where My Grandfather Is Buried, but I Want to Mark Where He Lived

February 24, 2021
Republican Senator from Missouri Josh Hawley

Trump’s Acquittal and Republican Senators: Not Setting the Bar Low Enough

February 22, 2021
Why Not Equality for America’s Puerto Rican Men and Women?

Why Not Equality for America’s Puerto Rican Men and Women?

February 19, 2021
Refugee child holding up a sign reading 'we are human like you'

US Asylum Laws Must Catch up With the Reality of Today’s Refugees

February 18, 2021
Students with face masks go upstairs to their classrooms at the Petri primary school in Dortmund, western Germany, on August 12, 2020, amid the COVID-19 pandemic.

As America Accelerates Vaccine Distribution, Curiosity Turns to Kids

February 15, 2021
A tray of trial COVID-19 vaccines

There Is No Vaccine for Selfishness

January 29, 2021
Facebook Twitter

Newsletter

Do you like our reporting?
SUBSCRIBE

About Us

The Globe Post

The Globe Post is part of Globe Post Media, a U.S. digital news organization that is publishing the world's best targeted news sites.

submit oped

© 2018 The Globe Post

No Result
View All Result
  • National
  • World
  • Business
  • Interviews
  • Lifestyle
  • Democracy at Risk
    • Media Freedom
  • Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Columns
    • Book Reviews
    • Stage
  • Submit Op-ed

© 2018 The Globe Post